Cook: Pirates are being steered in a familiar direction
Share with others:
The baseball season has reached the quarter-pole, the perfect time to take a hard look at the Pirates. They have taken their usual bad turn -- Destination: Dreadful -- but what the heck? Let's start by accentuating the positive.
Neil Walker.
So much for that.
It really is a lot harder to pick the Pirates' biggest negative. Is it Pedro Alvarez? How about Lyle Overbay? Or maybe Neal Huntington?
I say Huntington.
The GM signed Overbay as a free agent in the offseason. He has been a bust so far.
The GM signed Matt Diaz. Bust.
The GM traded for Chris Snyder last season. Bust.
The GM really didn't want to bring Walker to the big leagues last season and did so only because Aki Iwamura was such a failure after the GM traded for him and his $4.85 million contract. Walker looks like the Pirates' All-Star, which is proof that it's sometimes better for the GM to be lucky than good.
The GM spent the winter unsuccessfully trying to trade for a shortstop because he knew Ronny Cedeno is maddeningly inconsistent. Cedeno has been maddeningly inconsistent.
The GM spent the winter unsuccessfully trying to trade Ryan Doumit because he didn't want to pay him $5.1 million to back up Snyder. Other than Walker, Doumit has been maybe the team's best hitter, which strengthens the case for lucky in that lucky-vs.-good argument.
But, hey, the Pirates' minor league system looks better!
Unless the big club shows dramatic improvement -- it lugs an 18-23 record and a six-game losing streak into Cincinnati tonight -- the next GM will get to reap the potential benefits because there's no way this GM will be back next season.
But Huntington's blunderings don't excuse Alvarez's poor performance. A slow start -- he's known for 'em -- is one thing. Hitting .210 on May 18 with one home run, seven RBIs and 41 strikeouts in 119 at-bats is hard to fathom or accept. If he keeps up at that pace for another few weeks, Huntington will have to consider letting him find his stroke in Class AAA Indianapolis. The team can't allow him to bury himself in the big leagues all season.
Nor is Overbay without blame. Huntington gave him a $5 million deal for this? Three home runs, 14 RBIs and, despite his reputation for being a top-notch fielder, four errors at first base?
For that matter, Andrew McCutchen and Jose Tabata -- two of Huntington's bigger building blocks along with Alvarez -- have been disappointing. McCutchen looked terrific on that triple against the Washington Nationals Monday night -- there is no more exciting play in baseball -- but those special moments with him have been rare this season. It's not so much that he has just five stolen bases after he promised to run more or even that he's hitting .242, a pretty lame number for the man considered by many to be the team's best player. He had to be benched by manager Clint Hurdler for not hustling. That's inexcusable.
First Published May 18, 2011 12:00 am
