Disgraced Fumo gets 55 months in jail
Share with others:
Former state Sen. Vincent J. Fumo was sentenced to 55 months yesterday for his federal corruption conviction.
Mr. Fumo, 66, a once-powerful Democrat, received the sentence from U.S. District Judge Ronald L. Buckwalter, who presided over the five-month trial that ended in March with Mr. Fumo's conviction on all 137 counts against him.
Mr. Fumo was also fined $411,000 and ordered to pay nearly $1.3 million restitution to the Senate, $676,000 to Citizens Alliance. He must report to jail on or before Aug. 31.
Just before he was sentenced, Mr. Fumo spoke for about 15 minutes.
"It's an embarrassment to stand here under these circumstances. All I can say your honor is I've done my best, given of myself, the things I did wrong, I never at the time thought they were."
Toward the end of his statement Mr. Fumo said, "Judge, I apologize that I put you through this, not just the trial. I had to make tough decisions in my life and I respect you. I can only ask for mercy and compassion. I tried to do the best job I did. I think I did a good job, and I did give back."
Outside the federal courthouse after court proceedings, Acting U.S. Attorney Michael Levy said the sentence "is a disappointment to the government."
Mr. Levy said that while the prosecution respects the judge, "we do not find the sentence was appropriate for the crimes that were committed."
Reached for comment after sentence, U.S. Rep. Bob Brady said Judge Buckwalter recognized Mr. Fumo's accomplishments.
"He did a lot with his life, and the judge took into consideration what he did for the little people, and a lot of people," Mr. Brady said. "He admitted his mistakes, he knew he made mistakes, and he had to pay for them."
Regarding Mr. Fumo's abilities and the prospect that he may have time to contribute when he gets out of prison, Mr. Brady said: "I'll give you this much -- if he was in the Senate, we'd have a budget by now."
Philadelphia City Council President Anna C. Verna, in a prepared, e-mailed statement, said:
"My first reaction is a purely human one. My heart goes out to Senator Fumo, his family and fiancee as they all begin what will surely be a very difficult time. I wish them the best. Representing many of the same constituents, I dealt often with the senator and his staff. I cannot think of a more effective advocate for so many worthwhile projects. Many of our citizens have benefitted greatly from his efforts. This is what I remember at this time. I leave the judgment to others."
In South Philadelphia this evening, Ed Novak, who was seated with his wife, Marilyn, on the steps of their Wharton Street home, said of Judge Buckwalter's 55 month sentence for Mr. Fumo: "I knew he was never going to jail for long. He did a lot for the people in South Philly."
Marilyn Novak added, "I'm not shocked. He knows a lot of people and has a lot of influence."
A jury of 10 women and two men found Mr. Fumo guilty of defrauding the state Senate and two nonprofits, tax violations and obstructing the FBI investigation.
Assistant U.S. Attorneys John J. Pease and Robert A. Zauzmer had asked Judge Buckwalter to impose a prison sentence of more than 15 years, while defense lawyers sought a sentence substantially shorter than the 11 to 14 years that could be imposed under the sentencing guidelines calculated by the judge.
They also asked the judge to fashion a sentence that would not be tantamount to death for Mr. Fumo, who they said has a shortened life expectancy because he suffers from heart problems, diabetes and other medical issues.
A lengthy prison term, they said, would in all likelihood mean that Mr. Fumo would die in prison.
Before today's sentencing, John Menenti, a Bureau of Prison's physician, challenged that assertion and suggested that prison would be a less stressful environment than the outside world of deadlines and cell phones.
Mr. Fumo, twice-divorced, is estranged from the oldest of his three children, a daughter whose husband worked for the senator and then became a key government witness.
Allie Fumo, 19, a University of Pennsylvania student who spoke on her father's behalf, said she now understands why she saw so little of him growing up.
"He may not have been a father to me but he was a father to other people, and I'll share him," she said.
Fiancee Carolyn Zinni, 51, a dress-shop owner, said prosecutors and reporters have raked Mr. Fumo over the coals.
"They stripped him of everything: his manhood, his character, his esteem, raking him over the coals, calling him a crook," Ms. Zinni said.
Co-defendant Ruth Arnao, a former Senate aide, faces sentencing next week on 45 counts. Also, two former state computer technicians pleaded guilty to systematically destroying Fumo e-mails.
First Published July 15, 2009 12:00 am