Grading the Pirates through the break

Share with others:


Print Email Read Later

Grading the Pirates' performance through the All-Star break, player by player, for those who spent more than a month on the active roster:

Starting pitchers Grade NoteworthyIan Snell A 5th-lowest ERA in league, staff-best 93 strikeouts. Outstanding.Tom Gorzelanny A 8th-lowest ERA in league, staff-best 9-4 record. Outstanding.Paul Maholm C- Twenty losses? Not now. Past nine starts have been solid.Zach Duke D- With .364 opponents’ average, every hitter was Ted Williams.Relievers Grade NoteworthyDamaso Marte A- Maybe majors’ best lefty specialist: Lefty hitters went 4 for 42.Matt Capps B+ 9 for 9 in saves as new closer, despite giving up too many hits.Shawn Chacon B Not so hot as starter, but averaging K per inning out of pen.Masumi Kuwata C That touchdown by the Brewers July 2 blew up his numbers.Salomon Torres C- Losing closer’s job, six blown saves, overshadow great May.John Grabow C- Struggles with fastball control responsible for 5.32 ERAJohn Wasdin D- Won job in spring training. Has not pitched well since.Tony Armas F Joins Burnitz, Randa on list of recent free-agent flops.Catchers Grade NoteworthyRyan Doumit B+ No telling what he might have done if he played more.Ronny Paulino D Offense, defense and even effort called into question.Infielders Grade NoteworthyFreddy Sanchez B Who can complain about .300, even if it is not a batting title?Jose Bautista C+ More needed from bat, but glovework has been golden at timesAdam LaRoche C Despite horrific start, on pace for 25 home runs, 100 RBIsJack Wilson C His .985 fielding percentage 3rd among league shortstops.Jose Castillo C- Fared well when starting, but rarely started. Not a bench guy.Don Kelly D Fell well short of becoming Pirates’ next Jose Hernandez.Outfielders Grade NoteworthyXavier Nady A- Platoon player? Not with 14 home runs, 50 RBIs. A leader, too.Jason Bay C+ Big reminder yesterday: He has 13 home runs, 56 RBIs.Nate McLouth C- Bats .293 as starter, but 4th outfielder 6 for 36 as pinch-hitter.Rajai Davis D+ Speed matters little with low average, erratic routes in outfield.Chris Duffy D Has yet to show he can perform in first half of a season.


Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here