 A
closer look at Plan B: Stadium building plans on fast
track
By Dan Fitzpatrick, Post-Gazette Staff Writer
This is the 11th in a series of articles taking a
closer look at ''Plan B,'' the financing mechanism
proposed by Pittsburgh and Allegheny County officials to
pay for new baseball and football stadiums and the
expansion of the David L. Lawrence Convention Center.
Today's installment is about probable timetables
for accomplishing an ambitious building plan.
Q: When would the two stadiums and a larger
convention center open for business?
A: The goal is to have the football and baseball parks
ready for their respective seasons in 2001. That's
roughly April 1 for the Pirates and Sept. 1 for the
Steelers. The David L. Lawrence Convention Center, which
plays host to groups year-round, has more leeway. The
target is 2001, but there ''is no hard deadline,'' said
the Allegheny Conference on Community Development's
Harold Miller, coordinator of a task force that discussed
the center's size and direction. ''A few months is not
going to make a whole lot of difference.''
Q: How long will it take to make all that happen?
A: Stadiums usually take 20 to 28 months to build. New
parks for the Baltimore Orioles, the Chicago White Sox,
the Cleveland Indians and the Colorado Rockies went from
shovel-in-the-dirt to opening day in two years' time.
Those with roofs, such as the Toronto Blue Jays' Skydome
and the Arizona Diamondbacks' Bank One Ballpark, took
longer. Both Toronto and Arizona waited three years.
Neither the Pirates nor the Steelers want a dome. So,
24 months should do the trick -- for the construction,
that is.
Most stadiums take two years to build, but another
year to plan.
After all, the buildings need to be designed, the
budgets needs to be set, the land needs to be acquired
and the materials need to be purchased. The Pirates and
the Steelers have to be as thorough as possible,
detailing their need for toilets, refreshments, office
space and the visitors' locker room, among other
requirements.
Also, the contracting and design team must settle on
the project's guaranteed maximum price. The workers will
be held to this number.
The owners and the contractor will also set a finish
date, obligating the building team to complete the
project by the agreed deadline. If not, some team owners
may exercise a so-called ''liquidated damage clause'' in
their contract with the stadium builders.
This clause, included with many large construction
projects, penalizes tardiness. Every day over the target
may cost the contractor $10,000, for example. The costs
can be higher, depending on the project. Some contracts
at the Pittsburgh International Airport carried damage
clauses of $25,000 per day.
No doubt, the schedule will be tight for either
stadium. So, ''the earlier you get started, the better
off you are,'' said Ray Steeb, general manager of Turner
Construction Co., a firm that has built 20 stadiums and
arenas for teams around the U.S. ''The determination to
go forward needs to happen right now.''
It will take six months to acquire the land. And
materials need to be purchased immediately, before they
have a chance to fluctuate in price and availability.
Which they will.
A year ago, for example, contractors had to wait 20
weeks for steel. Now, the delay is 14 weeks. Rarer still
are bar joists, the beams that support ceilings and
floors. They are taking 26 weeks to arrive on the job
site. Two years ago, lumber was in short supply. A year
from now, it could be cement. Who knows?
That's the point. Materials are the unknown variable
here. Stadium officials need to move soon if they want
the project to proceed on schedule, since national
manufacturers are struggling to keep pace with the demand
for new construction. Time and price will fluctuate
accordingly.
To purchase the materials, though, contractors need
more design information. Those renderings you've seen?
They're pretty pictures, but not much else. Contractors
need to have in their hands so-called schematic designs,
drawings that detail every joist, every brick.
Q: What about the convention center?
A: This project should follow the same timetable as
the stadiums: two years of construction, one year of
planning.
The new one in Philadelphia, called the Pennsylvania
Convention Center, took 24 months to build, and the
center is 1.2 million square feet, thousands of feet
larger than the expansion planned for Pittsburgh.
If Pittsburgh officials start the design this summer,
as promised, ''they can get that done in 2001,'' said Ron
Young, the Dick Corp. project manager for the
Philadelphia center. ''I don't see a problem with that.''
In most cases, convention centers are easier to build
than stadiums. They feature lots of wide-open spaces.
Complicating matters in Pittsburgh is the expansion,
which contractors will have to build while the rest of
the convention center stays in business.
Q: Can the deadline be met?
A: Bet on it. ''Would you want to be the contractor
responsible for Pirates not opening in April 2001?'' said
Dean Mosites, vice president with Mosites Construction
Co., another firm interested in the two stadium projects.
The strategy is no different for a large department
store or a new headquarters, experts said.
''If everything is planned correctly and materials hit
the job site at the right time, the construction will be
the easiest part of all this,'' Steeb said.
Think of it this way. The Empire State Building, one
of the world's largest skyscrapers, went from dirt to
spire in 13 months.
Some expect the ballpark contractor to have 20 months,
tops.
''Time is beginning to get short,'' Steeb said.
The firm that gets the job will probably have to
abandon the traditional design-bid-build method, which
separates the architectural process from the contracting.
Using the traditional method, it takes 15 months to do
the design, three months to hire the contractors and buy
the materials and then 24 months to build the stadium.
That's 3 1/2 years. Too long. The Pirates will be
wrapping up their 2001 season by then.
Instead, the builders and the designers will have to
work concurrently, using the so-called ''fast-track''
method. That should cut the time to 32 or 36 months.
There are ways to play catch-up, too.
Turner, for example, started work on the new
250,000-square-foot Lazarus department store and
underground parking garage at Fifth Avenue and Wood
Street six weeks later than it expected.
It built the supporting beams to street level and
poured the first-floor concrete, allowing the firm to
work up and down at the same time. Also, Turner could
have used one crane to build around the site. Instead, it
used two cranes, and it plans to have the store done in
half the time.
''A lot of pressure comes down on the contractors to
make it work,'' Mosites said.
Q: Who will build the stadiums?
A: Half a dozen firms are vying for both projects.
They include some of the biggest names in stadium
construction, from Turner Construction to Southfield,
Mich.-based Barton Malow Co. to Huber Hunt & Nichols
Inc., the Indianapolis-based general contractor that
built Three Rivers Stadium. Also, expect Kansas
City-based HOK Sport to compete for the architectural
contract on one, if not both, stadiums. The firm was
involved with early work on both projects. Several local
firms will probably seek participation, too.
The teams will most likely select a construction
manager to oversee the project. That manager, working
with the architects, will hire prime contractors for
various needs of the stadium, from electricity to
concrete to plumbing.
Expect the competition to be fierce. One stadium alone
could generate between 1,200 and 1,500 jobs per year of
construction, Steeb said.
(Do you have questions about the components of Plan
B? If so, send them to Dissecting Plan B, c/o Local News,
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 34 Blvd. of the Allies,
Pittsburgh, PA 15222.)
|