The WPIAL has a step-by-step system to break ties for spots in its football playoffs:
Head-to-head competition.
If there is a tie among three or more teams and head to head doesn't break the deadlock, then Gardner Points are used.
If there is still a tie, the WPIAL tiebreaker system is used.
(For example, if teams A, B and C are tied for two playoff spots and have 1-1 records in head-to-head competition, then Gardner Points will be used to break the tie. If team A has more Gardner Points, it would get one of the playoff spots. The tie between B and C then would be broken by head-to-head competition.
The system reverts back to head-to-head competition whenever possible to break ties among three or more teams.
If head-to-head competition can't break a tie among three or more teams, here is how the Gardner Points and WPIAL tiebreaker system work.)
Only conference games count.
In the Gardner Points system, the winning team gets 10 points for each of the defeated team's victories. (For example, Team A beat Team B. Team B has a 4-2 conference record, so Team A gets 40 points.)
Add up the Gardner Points for tied teams. If there is still a deadlock, the WPIAL tiebreaker system is used.
Under the tiebreaker system, a maximum of 10 points are earned in a victory and a maximum of 10 points are lost in a defeat. Points are based on comparative scores. (For example, a 9-0 victory is worth nine points. A 14-7 loss is minus-seven.)
Add up the tiebreaker points to come up with the playoff participant.
Mike White's "High School Sports Edition" videos are featured exclusively on PG+, a members-only web site from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Our introduction to PG+ gives you all the details.