
Even before the economic implosion, every wine consumer I know loved to talk about their greatest bargain finds. Billionaire Gordon Getty, owner of two high-end Napa Valley wineries, was recently quoted as saying, "There's enough of a cheapskate in me to relish a bottle that's a great bargain."
We all love the extra zing that scoring a great value brings. Thanks to the global glut of wine grapes, warehouses are overstocked, wine prices are dropping and more and more good values are coming on the wine market.
The cover story of the latest edition of The Wine Spectator (Oct. 15) features "500 Values $20 or Less." The list is broken into four quality-to-price categories. I have searched our state stores to find which of the best of these are available in Pennsylvania. This list is for wines of only 89 points or higher with the exception of those under $10, where I included 88 points. Although I normally do not include SLO wines in my recommendations, I have done so here for wines that merit the extra effort. SLO stands for "special liquor order" and requires ordering and prepaying a minimum number of bottles and waiting some days for the order to arrive. Prices in Pennsylvania vary from those listed in the article, sometimes slightly higher and other times considerably lower.
Here are a few of my personal under-$20 wine picks that you can find at area wine stores.
-- Elizabeth Downer
Henry Fessy Morgon Cru Beaujolais, 2007
PLCB # 15831, $13.99
A nice mouthful of sweet black cherries. Layered and complex with nice structure. Not your everyday Beaujolais, this is an excellent value.
Peter Lehman Barossa Shiraz, 2006
PLCB # 9341, $14.99
Given 91 points by Wine Spectator, this powerful Barossa shiraz has lots of smoky plums and chocolate aromas, some cedar and spice in the mouth and a long finish.
Altair Sideral Rapel Valley, Chile 2003
PLCB # 26278, $16.99
Masi Campofiorin Rosso del Veronese Ripasso, 2005
PLCB # 6188, $13.99
Made from corvina grapes in the Valpolicella region of Italy. The grapes have been dried before fermentation, intensifying the aromas and flavors. Entirely dry, it's a unique taste.
Louis Jadot Macon-Villages 2007
PLCB # 7206, $$11.99
This clean and tasty chardonnay comes from the Maconais region located between the Cote d'Or and Beaujolais in Burgundy. It is a worthy alternative to the pricey Burgundy chardonnays.
J. Vidal Fleury, White Cotes du Rhone, 2007
PLCB # 22346, $12.99
This label, owned by the Guigal family in the Cotes du Rhone, is known for well priced wines from the region. This is 100 percent viognier grape with nice nose of peaches, pear and honeysuckle.
C M S White blend, 2007
PLCB # 18262, $7.99
CMS stands for chardonnay, sauvignon blanc and marsanne, the grapes in this blend. With nice fruit and spice aromas and a stoney, mineral finish, it's a prize for this price.
In the $16 to $20, 90 points or higher category, the highest scoring bottle is an Australian shiraz with 92 points for $20. Unfortunately, it is not available here, nor are most of the 91 point wines at this price, but we do have two 91-point bargain reds from Chile. They are:
Vina Santa Rita Cabernet Sauvignon Maipo Valley Medalla Real 2006
PLCB # 22512, $16.99
Vina Santa Rita Carmenere Colchagua Valley Medalla Real 2007
PLCB # 22513, $16.99
From the Frankland River region of Australia with 90 points is Rocky Gully Shiraz Viognier 2007. Our stores do not have the '07 vintage but there is:
Rocky Gully Shiraz Viognier 2006
PLCB # 65132, $16.59 SLO six bottle minimum
Another interesting value from this category is a South African blend of the classic Bordeaux red grapes:
Glen Carlou, Paarl, 2005
PLCB #55202 $13.99, SLO six bottle minimum
For whites in this category, look for two 91 pointers. From New Zealand:
Coopers Creek Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough, 2008
PLCB # 67638, $14.99 SLO 12 bottle minimum
Mt. Eden Chardonnay Edna Valley, California 2007
PLCB # 54397, $25.89 SLO 12 bottle minimum
For wines priced from $13-$18, 85 points and higher there are two 90 pointers:
Ave, Mendoza Premium Malbec, 2007
PLCB # 41015 $13.49 SLO six bottle minimum
Bodegas Bilbainas Tempranillo Rioja 2006
PLCB # 72288 $16.69 SLO six bottle minimum
The following two wines scored 89 points:
Nugan Estate Cabernet Sauvignon Vision 2007, Australia
PLCB # 27506, $9.99
The Lackey Shiraz, South Australia, 2006
PLCB # 27897. $14.99
It was interesting to note Bodega Colome Amalaya, 2007 in this group with a score of 91 and costing $15. The 2006 vintage of this Argentine red blend was a Chairman's Selection selling for $9.99 earlier this year when I recommended it in this column. The entire stock was quickly gobbled up and there are only three bottles left in the entire state (none are in Allegheny County but if you want a bottle, ask your store to have PLCB #28600 transferred to you). Another Chairman's Selection that made this list with 90 points is Cupcake Sauvignon Blanc, Marlborough, 2008, which sold in Pennsylvania for $7.99. It also is entirely sold out.
In the $10 to $12 category of wines 83 points and higher there are nine reds scoring 89 or 90 points. None are available here. There is one white with 89 points:
Leasingham Riesling Clare Valley Magnus 2008
PLCB # 53910, $13.69 SLO 12 bottle minimum
In the under-$10 category there is an amazing bargain of a pinot noir scoring 88 points for $4. The wine is available in Pennsylvania but for some reason the price is almost triple the quote in the magazine:
Redtree Pinot Noir, California, 2008
PLCB # 55065, $10.99 SLO no minimum
In white, with 87 points there is:
Fetzer Valley Oak Chardonnay, 2008, California
PLCB # 06123, $9.99
This wine is also available in 1.5 liter bottles (#07409, $16.99) and at the outlet store in Washington, Pa., as two shrink-wrapped 750 ml bottles (# 8772 for $12.99).