EmailEmail
PrintPrint
Book Review: In 19th century New England, creative lives flower and intertwine
Sunday, March 30, 2008

This is a curious work of creative detection by a Mount Holyoke College professor who has spent many hours digging in the once-fertile soils of 19th-century New England.

Much of America's cultural heritage is buried there -- literature, art, belles lettres, religious expression and journalism -- because it flourished there in the middle of the century.

What Christopher Benfey manages, with some overreaching, is to reimagine that rich period in the private lives of some of its most creative souls.

There's Emily Dickinson, the Amherst, Mass., poet, whose genius was barely visible then; painter Martin Johnson Heade, an artist of exotic nature scenes; Harriet Beecher Stowe, the doughty novelist and professional scold; her brother, the Rev. Henry Ward Beecher, the nation's best-known clergyman and adulterer of the day; Thomas Wentworth Higginson, Dickinson's sometime literary mentor; and Mabel Loomis Todd, writer, painter, mistress of the poet's brother and savior of her poems.

Others who briefly touch this circle are Mark Twain, Florida developer Henry Flagler, Dom Pedro II, last emperor of Brazil and, by his poems and reputation, Lord Byron. Benfey considers his work, "The Prisoner of Chillon," a key influence on Dickinson and others.

The years of this book cover from the Civil War through the death of Dickinson in 1886 at 56. The pathologically shy yet startlingly wise poet compared herself to a hummingbird, the tiny creature whose presence is often felt, rather than seen, like Dickinson, the focus of this book.

Benfey's interpretation of her often difficult and obscure verse lends a poignancy to Dickinson's difficult life, where "hope was a thing with feathers" -- a hummingbird, perhaps?

Heade, who painted the birds among verdant foliage after visiting Brazil in the 1860s, is also important to Benfey's story. A solitary man who did not marry until he was 64, he seemed to anticipate the coming tragedy of the Civil War in his landscapes and seascapes of the 1850s marked by clouds and storms.

Benfey makes a host of connections between his varied crew of artists and public figures. His tender view of the relationships of these Victorian-era people adds a human dimension to what might have been just names in history books.

In Mabel Todd, a coquettish young woman who flirted with the infatuated Heade, Benfey finds his magnet, the person who tied together the various threads of his book.

She became Austin Dickinson's lover after moving from Washington, D.C., to Amherst when her husband, a rising astronomer, accepted a post at the college there.

After Emily Dickinson died, Mabel Todd was prepared to recognize the greatness in her poems through her relationship with Heade, who used the same images in his paintings, Benfey believes. She and Higginson collaborated to publish many of them, thus preserving America's most important poetry that otherwise would have never surfaced.

Benfrey, however fails to mention that the two badly edited and changed Dickinson's poems (they were not restored until 1955).

There are many stories in "A Summer of Hummingbirds," such as the development of Florida as a winter resort, the complicated lives of Stowe and her brother and the claim that Massachusetts jurist Otis Lord wanted to marry Emily Dickinson, but died before doing so.

Old newspaper columnists, when short on ideas, would often write on the topic, "things I learned while looking something else up." There's some of that approach to Benfey's book, yet he weaves a seductive tale with fascinating characters and a real appreciation for Dickinson and her poems.

He leads us to encounter the complexity and passions of a forgotten age and a group of fascinating people who seemed fated to obscurity.

Contact book editor Bob Hoover at bhoover@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634.
First published on March 30, 2008 at 6:46 pm
EmailEmail
PrintPrint