EmailEmail
PrintPrint
Easing pain through meditation illustrates mind's role in healing
Wednesday, January 30, 2008
As part of his stroke recovery, Andrew Annibale of Elliott receives an acupuncture treatment from Jennifer Whiteside, licensed acupuncturist at Allegheny General Hospital.

That chronic pain in your lower back probably can be eased by meditation, according to a new study by researchers associated with the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center.

Drs. Natalia Morone, Carol Greco and Debra Weiner did an eight-week study of 37 Pittsburgh area seniors aged 65 or older who complained of lower back pain.

Participants were taught three meditation techniques, and were assessed on measures of pain, physical function and quality of life after eight weeks, and again after three months.

"At the conclusion of the eight-week program, those with chronic low back pain noted a decreased amount of pain and a slight improvement in physical function," the researchers said in an article in the current issue of the journal PAIN. "At three-month followup the majority of patients were still practicing meditation, suggesting they had incorporated it into their daily lives because they had experienced an ongoing benefit associated with mindfulness meditation."

Meditation as medicine has its origins with Buddhism in ancient India. The program the UPMC researchers taught their test subjects was developed by Dr. Jon Kabat-Zinn of the University of Massachussetts.

"Previous studies have noted mindful meditation's benefits to those with chronic pain but its effects had not been noted on older adults exclusively and low back pain specifically," said Dr. Morone, a specialist in internal medicine. "With so many people seeking out alternative therapies, we felt it was our responsibility to study it scientifically."

Dr. Greco is a psychologist who teaches mindfulness meditation at UPMC's Center for Integrative Medicine in Shadyside. Meditation can relieve pain, she said, because meditation reduces stress and muscle tension, and "a lot of pain is exacerbated by muscle tension."

Less remarkable than the findings of the study was the fact that it was conducted by physicians at a leading research hospital. Not so long ago, Western medicine and Eastern medicine were at loggerheads. Now many doctors and hospitals see them more as partners.

"One reason more patients and doctors are embracing integrative medicine is its reported success rate at treating 'multisystemic' maladies -- health problems like fibromyalgia, arthritis, insomnia and high blood pressure -- which affect the brain as much as the body," said a news release from the famed Mayo Clinic in Minnesota.

UPMC and Allegheny General Hospital are among the nation's leaders in integrative medicine.

"Healing involves mind, body and spirit," said Dr. Barbara Nagrant, a clinical psychologist who runs the mind/body/spirit psychological services program at AGH. "Our body is always trying to be healthy. There are body work techniques that really help enhance people's natural healing ability."

Any hospitalized patient at Allegheny General Hospital may receive, free of charge, a Reiki treatment if he or she requests it, Dr. Nagrant said.

Reiki is a Japanese technique for stress reduction and relaxation that those who practice it say promotes healing. It's based on the premise that living beings have an energy field that surrounds them. In persons who are injured or ill, that energy field is disrupted. Reiki practitioners try to restore harmony by manipulating the energy field, sometimes without ever directly touching the patient.

"Most people feel a sense of calmness after [a Reiki treatment]," Dr. Nagrant said. "There have been numerous studies which show it reduces stress, anxiety, and blood pressure, and enhances the body's immune system."

Dr. Ronald Glick, medical director of UPMC's Center for Integrative Medicine, said his center doesn't offer Reiki because of the difficulty of verifying its effectiveness through traditional research methods.

"You can't test a placebo Reiki," he said.

Dr. Glick, a psychiatrist, is also licensed to practice acupuncture. A staple of traditional Chinese medicine, acupuncture is, like Reiki, based on the concept of restoring harmony to a disrupted energy field.

Acupuncture is thought to have originated with Shen Nung, a Chinese physician who lived about 4,700 years ago. Shen Nung theorized that the body has a life force -- which he called Chi -- running through it. When the flow of Chi through the body is disrupted, illness results. Chi flows through channels called meridians. Acupuncture points are where meridians come to the surface of the skin. By inserting needles at the points, the flow of Chi can be restored to normal.

Acupuncture stimulates production of endorphins -- pain-relieving chemicals in the body -- and "seems to help for every kind of pain," Dr. Glick said.

"I see just about any kind of pain," said Jennifer Whiteside, the acupuncturist for Allegheny General Hospital. "Acute pain, chronic pain. I also see patients who have anxiety or emotional difficulties, and patients who are going through chemotherapy."

Donna Anderson, 61, of Georgetown, Pa. who suffers from spinal stenosis, a narrowing of the lumbar (lower back) spinal canal that pinches the nerves to the skin and leg muscles, has been treated by Ms. Whiteside since July 2006.

"The pain was preventing me from even walking short distances," Ms. Anderson said. My doctor and I discussed surgery. I said: 'What about acupuncture?' He said 'great idea,' and recommended Jennifer."

Her pain receded measurably after her first session and "was pretty nearly gone" after four or five sessions, Ms. Anderson said.

Andrew Annibale, 46, of Pittsburgh, was sent to Ms. Whiteside by his doctor after he suffered a stroke a year ago. He's seeking to regain the full range of motion in his right arm, which was crippled by the stroke.

"I've seen much improvement," he said.

Benefits from acupuncture can be measured, said UPMC's Dr. Glick.

"If you put needles along a median, you can measure a change in electrical current" running through the body, Dr. Glick said.

It's still rare for medical doctors to refer their patients to acupuncturists and other practitioners of holistic medicine, but attitudes are changing, he said.

"A third of my patients are physician referrals," he said. "But in general, it's self referrals."

Medical education, especially at UPMC, is paying more attention to the benefits holistic practitioners can offer, Dr. Glick said.

"We're closely connected to the residency program, both internal medicine and family medicine," he said.

But medical education still has some distance to go, Dr. Glick said.

"In general, we learn very little about diet and nutrition in medical school," he said.

Both UPMC's Center for Integrative Medicine at 580 S. Aiken Ave. in Shadyside and Allegheny General Hospital's Integrated Medicine Program at 1307 Federal St. offer a wide range of services, including shiatsu and Swedish massage, reflexology (massaging the feet to improve general health), and nutritional counseling. Some are covered by insurance. For more information, contact the Center for Integrative Medicine at 412-623-3023, or the Integrated Medicine Program at 412-359-8951.

The Reiki program for hospitalized patients at AGH is run by volunteers. If you're a Reiki practitioner and would like to help, Dr. Nagrant would like to speak to you. Her number is: 412-359-8209.

Jack Kelly can be reached at jkelly@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1476.
First published on January 30, 2008 at 12:00 am
EmailEmail
PrintPrint