1930s: 1939, Billy Conn.

1940s: 1940, Fritzie Zivic; 1941, Aldo T. "Buff" Donelli; 1942, Bill Dudley; 1943, Rip Sewell; 1944, Frankie Frisch; 1945, Billy Conn; 1946, Bill Dudley; 1947, Ralph Kiner; 1948, Bill Meyer; 1949, Ralph Kiner.

1950s: 1950, Joe Geri; 1951, Murry Dickson; 1952, L.P. "Red" Dawson & Stan Musial; 1953, Lew Worsham; 1954, D.W. "Dudey" Moore; 1955, John Michelosen; 1956, Dale Long; 1957, Dick Groat; 1958, Danny Murtaugh; 1959, Elroy Face.

1960s: 1960, Arnold Palmer & Dick Groat; 1961, Roberto Clemente; 1962, Lou Michaels; 1963, John Michelosen; 1964,.....Delvin Miller; 1965, Vernon Law; 1966, Roberto Clemente; 1967, Aldege "Baz" Bastien; 1968, Steve Blass & Dick Hoak; 1969, John "Red" Manning.

1970s: 1970, Danny Murtaugh; 1971, Roberto Clemente, Willie Stargell & Danny Murtaugh; 1972, Chuck Noll; 1973, Johnny Majors; 1974, Joe Greene; 1975, Terry Bradshaw; 1976, Tony Dorsett; 1977, Dave Parker; 1979, Willie Stargell.

1980s: 1980, Hugh Green; 1981, Jackie Sherrill; 1982, Joe Paterno; 1983, Dan Marino; 1984, John Stallworth; 1985, Louis Lipps; 1986, Mario Lemieux; 1987, Syd Thrift; 1988, Mario Lemieux; 1989, Roger Kingdom.

1990s: 1990, Jim Leyland; 1991, Bob Johnson; 1992, Bill Cowher; 1993, Jay Bell; 1994, Bill Cowher; 1995, Jaromir Jagr; 1996, Kurt Angle; 1997, Jerome Bettis; 1998, Joe Paterno; 1999, Mario Lemieux.

2000s: 2000, Jason Kendall; 2001, Kordell Stewart; 2002, Ben Howland; 2003, Larry Fitzgerald; 2004, Ben Roethlisberger; 2005, Jerome Bettis; 2006, Sidney Crosby.

1999: Suzie McConnell Serio; 2000: Dori Anderson; 2001: Carol Semple Thompson, 2002: Swin Cash; 2003: Kelly Mazzante; 2004: Lauryn Williams; 2005: Agnus Berenato; 2006: Swin Cash.