On a visit to Carol Papas' garden in O'Hara, the gardener purposefully directs the photographer away from herself and toward her garden.
And in her garden, one of five that will be featured during the Audubon Society of Western Pennsylvania Secret Garden Tour on Monday, plants rule.
They're mostly perennials, lushly planted, but with a good bone structure of trees and conifers and a hardscape constructed by her father, stone mason Anthony Castelli. It's a garden that mirrors the spunky, welcoming personality of the gardener.
While Mrs. Papas is quick to credit those who have helped her along the way, it is clear that the vision for the space is hers alone. She labors on a difficult plot, less than an acre, on a steep hillside. The vast majority of the garden is in the rear of the dwelling.
When she and her husband, Spiro, moved in, there was no garden to speak of, and she wasn't a gardener. These days, she's not only a certified master gardener who gives classes at Phipps, she operates her own small business, doing garden designs that specialize in mixed borders, and also some custom containers for a limited number of clients.
![]() |
|
A container she made sits in front of the waterfall at her O'Hara home. Click photo for larger image. |
"I do it all myself," she says.
Dr. Spiro Papas, who is a surgeon, has on occasion helped prune a few things, something he is good at, his wife says, laughing.
Her children, including a son, pitch in from time to time, but Mrs. Papas is protective of her little space. It's been a peaceful refuge for her over the years.
When she first took on the project, she got help with the "bones" of the space from Lindsay Bond Totten, who did the drawing for her about 15 years ago. (Ms. Totten is now the president of the Botanic Garden of Western Pennsylvania and no longer does private garden design.) The drawing helped her incorporate trees, like the Stewartia that she knew she wanted but wasn't sure where to place.
![]() |
|
A bellflower in Carol Papas' garden in O'Hara. Click photo for larger image. |
Ms. Totten took the circle idea for the patio and elaborated on the theme, giving it a rippling effect into the surrounding landscape, using circular cement borders filled with grass.
After that, it was up to Mrs. Papas to plant. She created lush beds filled with perennials such as rich, sky-blue campanulas, carmine-red poppies, astilbe, hosta, roses and clematis.
"The garden is intensely planted," she says. "It's a garden for real gardeners."
Her pots are also works of art. She incorporates unusual things in them; she hates to repeat herself. It's her theory that containers are one thing that you shouldn't be afraid to experiment with. After all, they are ephemeral. If you don't like what you create, you can always change it. Tearing a pot apart is much easier than moving a tree you've put in the wrong place.
![]() |
|
Fuchsia 'Gartenmeistar,' oxalis, begonia and a coleus cultivar. Click photo for larger image. |
A pool was added to the landscape in a difficult space, tucked into the hillside below the garden proper. It was accomplished with lots of earth-moving and wall-building. Three sides of the pool are paved, but the third is planted with perennials, interspersed with pots. The plants that live there must be tough because the soil is very poor. Mrs. Papas has selected daylilies, coreopsis, Rudbeckia maxima, crocosmia, helenium, feverfew, miscanthus and Lysimachia ciliata 'Purpurea' for the area. It turns out that these hardy plants all come from the hot part of the color palette.
Smiling, she says that her kids only see her from the rear during pool season because she's busy weeding while they swim.
The pool brings one other benefit: Because the property had to be fenced, deer, which are a huge problem in O'Hara, have been fenced out.
"Greek" Brittany spaniel Yorba does the rest of the varmint control. He's a constant companion to Mrs. Papas in the yard, and a friendly boy to visitors.
She's working on a relatively new addition to the landscape, a small pond. Fish swim languidly among the water plants. Mrs. Papas says this area is still very much a work in progress. She hopes to coax some of the new plantings to overhang the pool and "soften" the edges of the structure as they mature.
Like most gardens, Mrs. Papas' space has taken on her distinct personality, though she says she was heavily influenced by gardening friends such as Sally Foster, Betsy Byerly, Bobbie Martha and Jane Pasman, all members of the Fox Chapel Garden Club.
And like most gardeners, she's never done with her work. As a reporter and photographer pulled away, she pointed to an area in the front yard and said, "I'll do something with this before the tour."