About the teams: The Post-Gazette Fabulous Five and the WPIAL and City League All-Star teams were selected by the Post-Gazette scholastic sports staff. All-section teams were picked by the coaches.
| WPIAL CLASS AAAA | |||||
| Name | School | Ht | .Yr | .Pos | .Avg. |
| Jawaan Alston | Albert Gallatin | 6-8 | Jr | .C-F | 20.6 |
| Andrew Devlin | Mt. Lebanon | 6-6 | Jr | .F | 15.1 |
| Robert Doiley | McKeesport | 5-9 | Sr | .G | 13.0 |
| Mike Sherry | Chartiers Valley | 6-1 | Jr | .G | 20.1 |
| Ryan Tiesi | North Allegheny | 6-1 | Sr | .G | 16.8 |
| Player of the Year -- Andrew Devlin, Mt. Lebanon | |||||
| WPIAL CLASS AAA | |||||
| Name | School | Ht | .Yr | .Pos | .Avg. |
| Zack Fetchin | Hopewell | 6-5 | Sr | .G-F | 16.0 |
| Josh Gumbert | Blackhawk | 6-1 | Jr | .G | 15.2 |
| Jordan Shoop | Knoch | 6-3 | Sr | .G | 18.9 |
| Steve Swiech | Elizabeth Forward | 6-9 | Jr | .F-C | 26.8 |
| Dan Walsh | Moon | 6-1 | Sr | .G | 12.0 |
| Player of the Year -- Steve Swiech, Elizabeth Forward | |||||
| WPIAL CLASS AA | |||||
| Name | School | Ht | .Yr | .Pos | .Avg. |
| Lance Jeter | Beaver Falls | 6-3 | Sr | .G | 20.2 |
| Steve McNees | Shenango | 6-2 | Sr | .G | 28.4 |
| Herb Pope | Aliquippa | 6-9 | Jr | .F-C | 18.3 |
| Terrelle Pryor | Jeannette | 6-6 | So | .F | 21.5 |
| Josh Taylor | Brentwood | 6-7 | Sr | .F-C | 22.4 |
| Player of the Year -- Herb Pope, Aliquippa | |||||
| WPIAL CLASS A | |||||
| Name | School | Ht | .Yr | .Pos | .Avg. |
| Jason Duty | Vincentian | 5-11 | Sr | .G | 17.5 |
| Elijah Fields | Duquesne | 6-2 | Sr | .G-F | 18.9 |
| Rashawd Hatten | Clairton | 6-4 | Sr | .F | 17.6 |
| Matt Metcalf | O.L. Sacred Heart | 6-2 | Jr | .G | 21.7 |
| Marc Rozanski | Serra | 6-4 | Jr | .G | 15.9 |
| Player of the Year -- Elijah Fields, Duquesne | |||||
| CITY LEAGUE | |||||
| Name | School | Ht | .Yr | .Pos | .Avg. |
| DeJuan Blair | Schenley | 6-7 | Jr | .F | 17.0 |
| D.J. Kennedy | Schenley | 6-5 | Jr | .G | 16.8 |
| Marcus Robinson | Allderdice | 6-3 | Sr | .G-F | 16.2 |
| Brad Runco | Allderdice | 6-2 | Sr | .G | 16.7 |
| Cory Somerville | Perry | 6-6 | Jr | .F-C | 13.8 |
| Player of the Year -- DeJuan Blair, Schenley | |||||