Pope envy: Other denominations would like to have a leader like Francis
December 7, 2013 7:02 PM
Vincenzo Pinto/Getty Images
Pope Francis chose his papal name because St. Francis of Assisi was "a man of poverty and a man of peace."
By Alex Beam / Boston Globe
Pope Francis (nee: Jorge Mario Bergoglio) has shaken up the Roman Catholic Church with some plain speaking about faith and life in the 21st century. He has had an impact on other faiths, as well. Welcome to “pope envy.”
I first encountered the term in an essay by Jana Riess, a liberal Mormon writer. “I’ve delighted in seeing this beautiful revitalization of hope in the Catholic Church,” Ms. Riess wrote, “but I’ve also felt twinges of (an admittedly un-Christian) envy.”
Why wouldn’t a Mormon, or anyone for that matter, envy the un-self-conscious spiritual leadership of a prelate who warns nuns that there is more to the monastic life than just smiling for God and who sneaks out of the Vatican, disguised as a parish priest, to minister to the homeless?
Furthermore, as Ms. Riess notes, Pope Francis is very much out there in the world. The Mormons’ “Prophet, Seer and Revelator,” 86-year-old Thomas Monson, chosen by seniority rather than by merit, “is unusual in his distance from the public, the media and his own followers,” she writes. In Mr. Monson’s rare appearances, “almost nothing was unscripted. He does not do press conferences, and seldom fields unexpected questions.”
Comparisons are otiose, of course, but Pope Francis is anything but cloistered from reality. At times, he seems to yak on about whatever comes to his mind, just as you and I do. He has said that he lives in a hotel rather than in the isolated papal apartments “for psychiatric reasons.”
Pope Francis plays odd pranks, dispensing rosary beads packaged as pharmaceuticals, or donning a clown’s nose. I don’t know why he acts this way — because he feels like it?
Rabbi Jeffrey Salkin recently evinced some ecumenical envy in the Jewish Daily Forward. After calling Pope Francis “the most ‘Jewish’ pope we have ever encountered,” Rabbi Salkin went on to praise his literacy, compassion and his outreach to Jews in his native Argentina.
“It is enough to create pope envy,” Rabbi Salkin said. It is indeed. I understand that many readers of this column may have little use for the serried pieties of organized religion. But, apart from Pope Francis, who dares to speak with moral authority these days?
Money-grubbing college presidents, hiding behind their amassed endowments and their fancy new athletic centers? Don’t make me laugh.
The man in the White House? As if. I have trouble imagining either Barack Obama or George W. Bush decrying the “economy of exclusion and inequality” ravaging the world today. Both men have avidly licked the boots of the titans of capital.
Not Pope Francis. “Today everything comes under the laws of competition and the survival of the fittest, where the powerful feed upon the powerless,” he recently opined. He’s tossing the doctrine of St. Milton Friedman out the window, condemning “a crude and naive trust in the goodness of those wielding economic power and in the sacralized workings of the prevailing economic system. Meanwhile, the excluded are still waiting.”
The Mormons, the Jews … what about my co-communicants, God’s Frozen People, the Episcopalians? We jettisoned the pope almost five centuries ago; what do we have to show for it?
We have a wonderful bishop where I live in Massachusetts, Thomas Shaw, who has some vague reporting relationship to a presiding bishop in New York, a former marine biologist named Katharine Schori. She in turn owes some fealty, or lack thereof, to the Archbishop of Canterbury in Great Britain, a woolly figure of occasional ridicule in the sharp-elbowed British press.
The man currently warming the Anglican throne is Justin Welby, a former oil executive who was “enthroned” in March. Rev. Welby has inveighed against high energy prices, against excessive materialism at Christmastime and has condemned celebrities such as Katy Perry and Madonna (!) for wearing the cross as a fashion accoutrement.
Perhaps he is on the right track. But I say, enviously: He’s no Pope Francis. Few are.
Alex Beam is a columnist for the Boston Globe (alexbeamhotmail.com).
To report inappropriate comments, abuse and/or repeat offenders, please send an email to
firstname.lastname@example.org and include a link to the article and a copy of the comment. Your report will be reviewed in a timely manner.