 
|
|
              
|
JUDGE OF SUPERIOR COURT 10-year term; vote for no more than 2 TERM: 10 years SALARY: $119,016 DUTIES: The Pennsylvania Superior Court is one of two intermediate appellate courts. It hears all criminal and civil appeals from the Courts of Common Pleas except for death penalty cases and those which are specifically assigned to the Commonwealth Court. The Court has 15 judges, with the President Judge elected by the members. Judges of the Superior Court must be lawyers and must reside in Pennsylvania for at least a year before their election and for as long as they continue in office. QUESTION ASKED: Why do you wish to serve on the Superior Court of Pennsylvania? Republican Richard B. Klein Age: 60; Philadelphia EDUCATION: B.A. Amherst College; J.D. Harvard Law School. OCCUPATION: Judge, Court of Common Pleas. QUALIFICATIONS: Twenty-five years as state trial judge. Leadership in justice improvement efforts, including vice-chair of Pennsylvania Futures Commission; leadership in bar, court system committees. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Experience as a judge will enable me to be an immediate asset to the court without the need for "on-the-job" training. In this period of unprecedented change, the court system must adapt while at the same time preserving our core values. I can use my leadership experience on the Pennsylvania Futures Commission and at the American, Pennsylvania, and Philadelphia bar association level to improve the state justice system. Maureen E. Lally-Green Age: 50; Pittsburgh Area EDUCATION: B.S., Duquesne University; J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Judge, Superior Court. QUALIFICATIONS: Twenty-five years experience in various aspects of the law: full-time professor of law and author of numerous scholarly articles (1983-98); part-time consulting with two justices of Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court (1985-88; 1989-98); counsel to private corporation (1978-83); counsel to public agency (1975-78); private law practice (1974-75). ANSWER TO QUESTION: Our Superior Court of Pennsylvania is regarded as one of the most influential and efficient courts in the United States. It would be my privilege to continue to serve as an elected member of this Court and to work toward preserving and improving that reputation. Service as a judge permits me the opportunity to use my experience with the law in an important way and also to serve the people of this commonwealth. Democrat Debra Todd Age: 42; Pittsburgh Area EDUCATION: B.A. Chatham College; J.D., University of Pittsburgh Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Seventeen years trial experience; rated "highly qualified" by the Allegheny Bar Association; "recommended" by the Pennsylvania Bar Association, which added, "A person of high integrity with a strong commitment to fairness… held in high regard by the bench and bar." ANSWER TO QUESTION: Administration of justice is enhanced when highly qualified individuals are elected to the judiciary. It is incumbent upon us all to seek and promote the most qualified, motivated, and diligent candidates who will serve the commonwealth with dignity, honesty and respect for both the law and litigants. It is likewise important that our courts reflect the diversity of our commonwealth. I believe my background and breadth of experience will favorably contribute to that diversity.
Berle M. Schiller Age: 55 EDUCATION: B.A. Bowdoin College; J.D., New York University Law School. OCCUPATION: Judge, Superior Court of Pennsylvania, since 1996; appointed by the governor and unanimously confirmed by state Senate. QUALIFICATIONS: Twenty-five years of trial and appellate practice, civil and criminal; directed Pennsylvania’s first narcotics strike force; chief counsel of the Federal Transit Administration, 1994-1996; disciplinary board of Supreme Court. ANSWER TO QUESTION: The responsibility of public service on the Superior Court permits me to bring broad professional and community experience to the bench. Aside from professional qualifications, I am a past home and school president, former mental health center chairman and active father of four children. I bring a unique combination of skills, experience, integrity and sensitivity to a position that requires them. Pennsylvanians should demand no less. With your help, I will continue on the Superior Court. ALLEGHENY COUNTY JUDGE OF THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS Vote for no more than 2 TERM: 10 years SALARY: $111,657 DUTIES: Four Divisions: Civil, Orphans, Criminal, Family. If there are fewer than six judges in the division, salary is $111,657. If there are more than 6 judges in the division, the salary is $112,191. QUESTION ASKED: What specific suggestions do you have for improving the administration of justice in Allegheny County? Republican Susan Ruffner Age: 47; Squirrel Hill EDUCATION: B.A., University of Pittsburgh, J.D., George Washington University Law School. OCCUPATION: Judge, Court of Common Pleas, Juvenile Division. QUALIFICATIONS: Assistant district attorney, (1977-84); deputy chief counsel, Department of Auditor General (1989-91); chief magistrate, Pittsburgh Magistrates Court (1991-94); chief counsel, Port Authority (1994-97); currently a judge of the Court of Common Pleas. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Delay in the courts must be addressed to reduce costs and inconvenience for litigants, witnesses and lawyers. When I was Chief Magistrate of the state’s second-busiest court, I crafted workable solutions to problems caused by growing caseloads and limited resources. As a judge in Juvenile Court, I am dedicated to fairness and administering equal justice with every decision I make. Deborah S. Miskovich: No Reply Daniel L. Sautel Age: 50; Whitehall EDUCATION: Wheeling Jesuit University, University of Dayton Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney at law. QUALIFICATIONS: General practitioner representing individuals and small businesses in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas Civil, Criminal, Family and Orphan’s Court Divisions. More than 15 years experience handling hundreds of cases in state and federal courts, in arbitration, non-jury and jury trials, and practice before numerous local, state and federal administrative agencies and departmental proceedings. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Electing judges with adequate education and experience is not enough. We need judges who are committed to work at least as hard as judges as they did as lawyers. In my case, that means 50-60 hours per week. Administratively, in most divisions of the court, scheduling hearings at reasonable time intervals, rather than all at the same time, could save parties significant costs (i.e. attorneys fees) without adversely affecting court efficiency. Also, judges should be required to issue rulings and opinions according to specific deadlines. Frank Cecchetti Age:50; Mt. Lebanon EDUCATION: B.A., Duquesne University; J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: More than 23 years of trial experience. ANSWER TO QUESTION: I firmly believe every member of the judiciary should fulfill the obligation to dispose promptly of the business of the court. The time demands of the caseload require that a judge begin promptly each morning to bring to a conclusion those matters before the court. I understand and accept that responsibility. Beth Williams Age: 43; Aspinwall EDUCATION: B.S., Pennsylvania State University; J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney, sole practitioner. QUALIFICATIONS: Eleven years of experience practicing law in each division of the court system in Allegheny County; pro bono service for N.L.S. and Family Hospice; community service in local and regional organizations. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Stricter adherence to time and date schedules for all parties involved in a particular legal proceeding, including jurors, parties, witnesses, attorneys and judges. Less ability to postpone cases. Continuation and expansion to other divisions (where possible) of the current system in place in the family division of one judge to one case. This judge would be familiar with the case and the prior proceedings and could issue orders and decisions on a more timely basis. Gene Scanlon Jr. Age:52; McCandless EDUCATION: B.A., University of Pittsburgh; J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Judge. QUALIFICATIONS: Ten months service as judge in Family Division of A.C.C.P.; 26 years civil trial lawyer; member, Academy of Trial Lawyers of Allegheny County; highly recommended by Bar Association; appointed as judge by Gov. Ridge after recommended by his search committee. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Civil Division judges should have their own trial calendar to allow for better control of case load and scheduling of trials. In Family Division, courtrooms must be available for business earlier in the day than 9:30 a.m. Partial custody hearings require more than 30 minutes attention and should be given higher priority. In Criminal Division, the District Attorney and Public Defender offices must be staffed to handle the growing case loads to allow more time for each to prepare cases. Catherine A. Conley Age: 38; Ross Township EDUCATION: B.A., Pennsylvania State University, J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney; sole practitioner since 1990. QUALIFICATIONS: Appellate law clerk to Honorable Bernard L. McGinley, Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania; experience in every division of the Court of Common Pleas; experienced in federal court; experienced before every Pennsylvania appellate court and before the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals. ANSWER TO QUESTION: In every division of the Court of Common Pleas, there should be more direct, face-to-face contact with the judge rendering a decision in a case. Often, it’s only at a final hearing that a judge meets a litigant, and sometimes not at all. Justice would be better served if individual litigants had more contact with the decision-maker in a case, throughout the course of the case. In Family Division, a priority would be to eliminate the hours of delay in calling a case and waiting for a hearing on the sixth floor. Phil Melograne Age: 38; Whitehall EDUCATION: B.A., J.D., University of Pittsburgh. OCCUPATION: Attorney/Partner, LoPresti, Melograne, Stewart & Zinski. QUALIFICATIONS: Allegheny County Assistant District Attorney -- extensive trial experience with homicides, assaults, sex assaults, child abuse, theft, narcotics. As a private trial attorney, involved in civil litigation, juvenile proceedings, family law and criminal defense. ANSWER TO QUESTION: A judge’s primary obligation is to ensure justice. In fulfilling this obligation, a judge must ensure that all persons participating in the court proceeding leave knowing that their efforts have fulfilled a purpose. A participant’s role in any proceeding is just as important as that of the attorneys and the judge. Too often, parties feel frustrated. A judge must be cognizant of their roles, the value of their time and the importance of their participation. Mike McCarthy Age:49; Ross. EDUCATION: B.A., J.D., Duquesne University. OCCUPATION: Administrative chairman, Court of Common Pleas. Board of Viewers, Fifth Judicial District. QUALIFICATIONS: Recommended by Allegheny County Bar Association. Former Allegheny County Assistant District Attorney. Former Allegheny County detective. Vietnam Veteran, U.S.Navy Seabees ANSWER TO QUESTION: Justice delayed is justice denied. All cases must be addressed as quickly as possible to ensure fairness to all of the parties. As my record as Administrative Chairman for the Board of Viewers shows, I have reorganized and managed the Board so that I have eliminated case backlog in my office. This is vitally important to improving the administration of justice in our county as well.
Jerry DeRiso Age: 57; Monroeville EDUCATION: B.S., B.A., J.D., Duquesne University. OCCUPATION: Attorney QUALIFICATIONS: I have practiced law for over 32 years in all four divisions of the court. I was a hearing examiner for 12 years for the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board and decided thousands of cases from licensing matters to nuisance bars. ANSWER TO QUESTION: It is imperative to properly staff and fund the Family Division of the Court of Common Pleas in order to timely and properly dispose of juvenile and domestic matters in a dignified environment. Frivolous lawsuits which overburden the system and delay the administration of justice must be stopped. Perhaps a penalty assessed against lawyers who bring such actions should be considered. William T. Simmons Age:49, Lincoln-Larimer EDUCATION: J.D., University of Pittsburgh Law School. OCCUPATION: Chief magistrate, City of Pittsburgh QUALIFICATIONS: Since 1995, I have presided over the following City Courts: Arraignment, City, Traffic, Housing, Domestic Violence, Child Sexual Abuse/Endangerment, Special Hearings and Underage Drinking. ANSWER TO QUESTION: I plan to do the same thing I did in City Magistrates Court: review the existing courts and institute changes to improve their operation and outcome. For example, I was alarmed at the number of underage alcohol abusers that came through the system and, as a result, instituted the Underage Drinking Court. Offenders chose the sentencing or the program, which includes drug/alcohol evaluation, AA meetings, and an interactive visit to the jail or morgue. Randy Todd Age: 44; Mt. Lebanon EDUCATION: B.S., B.A., Pennsylvania State University, J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: I am an experienced trial attorney who is also the former managing partner of DeMay, DeMay, Donnelly & Todd. As such, I bring not only legal experience but the ability to manage a large practice, which will be an asset to the taxpayers. ANSWER TO QUESTION: The biggest issue facing our courts today is the high volume of cases, which has slowed down every division. We need dedicated, hard-working men and women with the ability to make sure everyone is treated fairly and justice is served. The taxpayers deserve no less. As an attorney who has always worked in the private sector, I would bring a strong work ethic and the ability to manage a successful practice to the bench.
Gayle Godfrey Age: 50; Cheswick EDUCATION: B.S., Indiana University of Pennsylvania; J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Trial lawyer and partner with Weis & Weis for 15 years; highly recommended by the Allegheny County Bar Association; fellow of the Academy of Trial Lawyers; nine-year board member, Rachel Carson Homestead Association; chair, Health Law Section, Allegheny County Bar Association. ANSWER TO QUESTION: As has been stated by many great jurists, justice delayed is justice denied. Trial continuances that are routinely and liberally granted are prejudicial to victims who seek justice and closure. The memory and availability of witnesses diminish with time and trial delays. Every effort should be made by the judiciary to ensure that cases are tried promptly and fairly and that requests for continuances granted only when truly in the interests of justice.
Terry McVerry Age: 56; Mt. Lebanon EDUCATION: B.A., J.D., Duquesne University. OCCUPATION: Judge, Court of Common Pleas. QUALIFICATIONS: Practicing attorney for 30 years as assistant district attorney and trial attorney in private practice. Bar Association rating: Highly Recommended for Judicial Office. Member, Pennsylvania House of Representatives, 12 years. Active in community, church and family. ANSWER TO QUESTION: My goal is to improve the public perception of the Court of Common Pleas. I believe this is accomplishable by each judge rededicating him/herself to the notion that we are public servants and work for the people. As judges, we must conduct ourselves with not only diligence and decorum, but also patience, compassion and common sense to assure that people leave their court experience with a sense that fair play and justice were afforded to all. James E. Durkin Age: 53; Monroeville EDUCATION: B.A., J.D., Duquesne University. OCCUPATION: Trial attorney since 1977, representing clients in all divisions of Common Pleas Court and in the state Appellate Courts. QUALIFICATIONS: Twenty years of broad experience in civil and criminal trials, hearings, arbitrations, magistrate and master proceedings. Working throughout college and law school has given me the work ethic and values necessary for the bench, while representing individuals has provided commitment to keeping the courts accessible and affordable to all people. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Would work to insure that court, District Attorney, and Public Defender offices are sufficiently staffed and trained to eliminate waste, delay and duplication. Would work to develop manuals and forms in simple terms to make public aware of how the judicial system works, increase understanding and eliminate confusion about that system. Would promote programs for adults and school children to give people a more realistic view of and approach to the courts. Eugene G. Berry Age: 45; Penn Hills EDUCATION: B.A., University of Notre Dame; J.D. University of Pittsburgh. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Rated highly recommended; 20 years experience as trial lawyer (Deputy Attorney General; litigation partner for Dickie, McCamey and Chilcote); fellow, Academy of Trial Lawyers; director/secretary, Port Authority; chair, Supreme Court Disciplinary Hearing Committee; special master; frequent lecturer for bar, business and social organizations; numerous directorships on not-for-profit boards. ANSWER TO QUESTION: I believe the present system can be improved by having one judge assigned to each case from beginning to end. In this manner, continuity will be ensured. I also believe a system should be implemented where some or even all of the judges would rotate through all the courts and become familiar and knowledgeable with each court. This will make for more-rounded judges. John L. Kwasneski Age: 42; McCandless EDUCATION: B.A., Clarion State College, J.D., Duquesne University School of Law. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Rated "recommended" by Allegheny County Bar Association Judiciary Committee; 17 years of trial work including three years as law clerk to U.S. District Court Judge; nominated in 1995 by Governor Ridge to fill vacancy on court. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Under the current system, when a lawsuit is filed, anywhere from four to five judges might deal with the case before it comes to trial. Then, when the case is called for trial, it is seen by a new judge for the first time the day of trial. I would institute an individual calendar system where each case is assigned to one judge to handle from start to finish, including all motions and discovery matters. Ronda Winnecour Age 44; Mt. Lebanon EDUCATION: B.A., University of Pittsburgh; J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Juvenile court master. QUALIFICATIONS: From 1979 to 1989, I was an assistant district attorney for Allegheny County; I prosecuted thousands of serious crimes in the courtroom, including murder; from 1989 to present, I have done the work of a Juvenile Court judge as the Allegheny County Juvenile Court master. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Juvenile Court is responsible for cases involving child abuse and neglect, school and community violence and juvenile delinquency. By tradition, it has been a training ground for judges who have little desire to serve there. I would like to make a long-term commitment to Juvenile Court bringing expertise and experience to help our children resolve the serious problems that face them today, to ensure community protection and give victims a voice in the process. Christine S. McCrady No Reply Bonnie Brimmeier Age: 40; Ross EDUCATION: B.A., Penn State University; University of Manchester, England; J..D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney, Dodaro, Kennedy and Cambest. QUALIFICATIONS: Municipal solicitor; solicitor, register of wills; practice in all state courts and all divisions of Court of Common Pleas, Federal Court, local and appellate. ANSWER TO QUESTION: No Reply. Daniel Sean McIntyre 47; Upper St. Clair EDUCATION: B.A., University of Pittsburgh; J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: More than 15 years extensive experience in all divisions of the Court of Common Pleas; broad experience in Workers’ Compensation, Unemployment Compensation, Social Security matters, Bankruptcy Court, Appellate Courts; excellent negotiation skills; good judicial temperament, hard working, honest, flexible, but firm; willing to listen. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Elect judges who are not only experienced in the law, but who are willing to work a full day. Judges who are considerate of the witnesses’, the parties’, and the attorneys’ schedules. Elect judges who are willing to compromise their own schedules if necessary, or to take witnesses out of order to accommodate emergency situations that do arise. Elect judges who take the time to be considerate and to listen to the witnesses and who do not pre-judge. James E. Mahood Age: 51; Richland EDUCATION: B.A., Bard College, J.D., University of Pittsburgh Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Twenty-five years experience in civil litigation; highest recommendation by Judiciary Committee of the Allegheny County Bar Association; Fellow, American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers; Chair, Pennsylvania Bar Association Family Law Section; member of PBA Code of Evidence Committee, and Advisory Committee to state Legislature on Adoption Law. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Prompt and consistent application of rules of procedure and law to cases to (1) expedite resolution of matters before the court; (2) increase predictability of result to litigants; and (3) encourage private settlement of disputes. Courteous treatment of litigants, witnesses and lawyers appearing before the court, while insisting on similarly courteous treatment of litigants, witnesses and lawyers by each other. Fair enforcement of orders and agreements so that cases can end and not be re-litigated endlessly. Frank Dermody No Reply Kevin G. Sasinoski Age: 46; O’Hara EDUCATION: B.A., University of Pittsburgh; J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Director, Allegheny County Public Defender’s office. QUALIFICATIONS: Eighteen years trial experience in all divisions of the court. As the director of the Public Defender’s Office, I manage a $4.3 million budget and 30,000 cases annually. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Clearly the court system here in Allegheny County is facing a funding crisis. Current funding for our local court system comes from the county in which the court operates. The greater caseload here in Allegheny County has not been met with appropriate increases in funding. I suggest that we move forward to implement the Supreme Court directive for a unified judiciary system, which calls for the uniform financing of the state courts by the Commonwealth. Frank J. Lucchino Age: 60; Highland Park EDUCATION: B.S., University of Pittsburgh, LLB, University of Pittsburgh Law School. OCCUPATION: Lawyer, County Controller. QUALIFICATIONS: Practiced law in Allegheny County for 34 years; tried cases in the civil, criminal, family and orphan’s court divisions as well as the U.S. District Court and all Pennsylvania Appellate Courts. ANSWER TO QUESTION: There is no real justice unless the courts are available to all the citizens of Allegheny County in a manner that they can afford. I would work to build on the systems that have been put in place to accomplish that goal. I also believe that jury service can be enhanced by spending the donated funds which have accumulated and remain unspent. These funds are earmarked only for facilities improvements. Bob Colville Age: 34; Brighton Heights EDUCATION: B.A., Pennsylvania State University, J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney practicing civil litigation with the law firm of Pietragallo, Bosick and Gordon in Pittsburgh. QUALIFICATIONS: Work ethic, energy and enthusiasm combined with scope and depth of experience. My work in the criminal justice system, as a legislative aide, as a law clerk for the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, and my current practice, in virtually every substantive area of civil litigation, uniquely qualifies me for the judiciary. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Let’s get back to basics. A judge must: 1) maintain unquestionable impartiality; 2) embrace the strictest work ethic; 3) dedicate himself to the task of clearly understanding and appreciating the law and the issues raised by the parties; and, 4) communicate the basis for his decisions to the parties. Nobody is ever pleased to lose a lawsuit. But, win or lose, we feel better about the "administration of justice" when the judge remembers the basics. Kim Clark Age: 43; North Side EDUCATION: B.A., Tennessee State University; J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Judge of the Court of Common Pleas; deputy and assistant district attorney, Allegheny County, 1983-1999. QUALIFICATIONS: I have extensive trial experience; I have tried approximately 150 jury trials, including 75 homicides; I have extensive community service work; I have dealt with witnesses and victims from all walks of life. ANSWER TO QUESTION: 1. The system could use more judges and staff so that cases are not rushed through the system or postponed repeatedly. 2. The system needs more participation of minorities as judges, lawyers, public defenders, prosecutors, jurors, court reporters, clerks, etc. to create an atmosphere of fairness. 3. We must understand that all who come into the system are human beings and should be treated with respect. If citizens are treated with respect, they will respect the system. Ruth A. Zittrain Age: 62; Churchill EDUCATION: B.A., Smith College, J.D., University of Pittsburgh Law School. OCCUPATION: Trial attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Successful practice on trial and appellate levels for 18 years: Common Pleas, Superior, and Supreme Courts of Pennsylvania; Personal injury, medical malpractice, probate, wills, estates, divorce, custody, will contests, contracts, etc. ANSWER TO QUESTION: (1) A comfortable, private place for litigants to await their hearings and trials instead of lining the hallways outside the courtrooms. (2) Judicial candidates should possess certain qualifications that will make them good judges: at least 10 years experience as lawyers; the ability and competence, proven by past record, to understand the law; a solid work ethic; judicial temperament toward litigants, attorneys, witnesses, and jurors; and compassion for victims balanced by justice for all. Dan Butler Age: 47; Pittsburgh’s 14th Ward EDUCATION: Duquesne Law School. OCCUPATION: Judge, Pittsburgh Magistrates Court. QUALIFICATIONS: In Family Court, I was a law clerk, hearing officer, custody mediator, and the first staff attorney prosecuting deadbeat dads. As a Judge in Pittsburgh Magistrates Court, I am in my sixth year of hearing a full range of criminal cases. ANSWER TO QUESTION: I make nonviolent offenders do community-service to benefit our community. Almost 3,000 have done so since I began this program. Teen-agers benefit from having the opportunity to see inside the system. Kids at risk gain a whole new attitude by spending a day on bench with me. As a Family Court Mediator, I settled over a thousand custody cases. I would devote more court time and energy to working cases out. Lynn MacBeth Age: 44; Penn Hills EDUCATION: B.A., Chatham College; J.D.,University of Pittsburgh Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Seventeen years experience as attorney concentrating in family, juvenile, and elder law; appointed by judges to hear court cases; officer and director of Family Mediation Council of Western Pennsylvania; author of articles on family law; recognized for pro bono work; listed in Who’s Who in American Law. ANSWER TO QUESTION: We need to make courts accessible to all people. In family law cases, we must maintain programs to help children who are sometimes the innocent victims. No violent criminal or sexual predator should ever be released into society without adequate protections. Prisoners must serve entire sentence before release. Punishment should fit the crime. Guido A. DeAngelis Age: 42; Bloomfield EDUCATION: B.A., Point Park College; J.D., Temple University School of Law. OCCUPATION: District Justice / Lawyer. QUALIFICATIONS: Fourteen years lawyer; nine years district justice; past president, Special Court Judges of Allegheny County; former law clerk to Judge David S. Cercone; law instructor Point Park College. ANSWER TO QUESTION: To encourage and plan measures in educating the public in the law and especially in the procedures of the legal system. Make use of administrative and technical skills to expedite case dockets and establish mechanisms for dispute resolution and case settlement. Work to unify the resources in the criminal justice system with efforts in rehabilitation of offenders and focus on victim’s rights and protections. Frank Salpietro Age: 37; Indiana Township EDUCATION: B.A., Emory University, J.D., University Pittsburgh Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: A strong work ethic, family values, integrity, 13 years’ trial experience; "recommended" by the Judiciary Committee as possessing "the highest reputation for integrity and the legal ability, experience and temperament to excel as a judge." ANSWER TO QUESTION: Judges must be held more accountable for the delay in reaching decisions. A system should be established to penalize judges for failing to reach a decision within a certain time frame unless there is a reasonable and legitimate excuse. It is simply unjust and unfair to have a person wait months or years for justice when a decision can be reached in days or weeks. As the saying goes, "justice delayed is justice denied." Moira Harrington Age:44; Spring Hill -North Side EDUCATION: B.S., Colorado State University; J.D., University of Pittsburgh Law School. OCCUPATION: Municipal Court judge for the City of Pittsburgh and an attorney in the law firm of Harrington Schweers Datillo & McClelland. QUALIFICATIONS: I have broad-based and extensive legal experience, both as a trial attorney in civil cases and as a "firm but fair" magistrate for the city. ANSWER TO QUESTION: As a judge in the Court of Common Pleas, I would improve the administration of justice by practicing and initiating those things that I have done as a judge for the city: Starting my court sessions on time, working diligently with all of the parties that appear before me to resolve disputes, broadening the scope of resolutions to include mediation where it would be appropriate, utilize alternatives to incarceration such as Drug Court, Domestic Violence Counseling, and Community Service. Kim Diane Eaton Age: 43; Brentwood EDUCATION: B.A., Pennsylvania State University; J.D., University of Pittsburgh Law School. OCCUPATION: Law partner in Rose, Schmidt, Hasley & DiSalle. QUALIFICATIONS: Rated "highly recommended" by Bar Association; supervisor of firm’s Family Law Section; appointed by judges to hear cases; recipient of Pennsylvania Bar Association’s Pro-Bono Award; frequent lecturer on family issues. ANSWER TO QUESTION: In Family Court, judges should promptly decide cases, particularly child custody cases, not just quickly, but fairly, by devoting more time and interest to individual situations. Children are traumatized by the divorce process, so mediation, counseling or just more attention from a judge may keep the matter out of court. A judge, as a public servant, should be willing to start the work day early, work later, and miss an occasional lunch hour to preserve families. Jacqueline Morrow Age: 42; Point Breeze EDUCATION: B.A. Clark University; J.D. University of Pittsburgh Law School. OCCUPATION: Solicitor, City of Pittsburgh. QUALIFICATIONS: Seventeen years experience handling the corporate and municipal issues adjudicated by the civil division of the court: (a) Chief Legal Officer of the City of Pittsburgh; (b) Corporate Counsel to Giant Eagle, Inc. and (c) Associate of Rose, Schmidt, Hasley and DiSalle. ANSWER TO QUESTION: How the justice system treats people in small matters tells them what it thinks of them in big matters. Judges must root out any inefficiency or delay in the system. We can reduce the time jurors sit waiting to be called or provide space for children to play while waiting for a hearing. If we fix the small problems the big problems will seem more solvable. Falco A. Muscante Age: 38; Lincoln Borough EDUCATION: B.A., J.D., Duquesne University. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Solicitor for 10 years and has had a private law practice for almost 12 years, with experience before all divisions of the Court of Common Pleas and all levels of the Pennsylvania and Federal Courts, including the United States Supreme Court. ANSWER TO QUESTION: As an attorney in private practice, I have represented numerous clients and have been concerned about the overall perception of the Court system and administration of justice in Allegheny County. Many clients have a negative perception that many judges do not devote their full energies to expeditiously resolving the court workload. Also, there is a perception that many people are not treated fairly or equally in the justice system. While these may only be perceptions, as Judge, I will constantly strive to demonstrate a strong and dedicated work ethic and will provide all parties with fair and equal treatment with protection and concern for their rights. Kevin J. Flaherty Age: 47; Penn Hills EDUCATION: Not provided. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Former public defender; former assistant district attorney; former judicial law clerk; general private practice, last eight years to the present. ANSWER TO QUESTION: As a former public defender, assistant district attorney and judicial law clerk, I have had the opportunity to practice before, and work with many excellent judges whom I have the utmost respect. If elected, I will bring that same work ethic and dedication to public service zealously to the bench on behalf of the citizens of Allegheny County in a fair and impartial manner. David K. McMullin Age: 57; Mt. Lebanon EDUCATION: B.A., J.D., Duquesne University. OCCUPATION: Attorney-at-Law in private practice QUALIFICATIONS: For almost 30 years, I have had a vigorous trial practice, having tried hundreds of cases in Common Pleas Court. My practice has included extensive appellate court work before the Superior and Supreme Courts of Pennsylvania and before the United States Supreme Court. ANSWER TO QUESTION: First, the law should be changed to permit judicial candidates to speak out on issues so that the voters would have a more intelligent basis for deciding between candidates rather than relying upon gimmicks. Secondly, a night court should be established in the civil division where cases, at the consent of all parties, could proceed to trial without parties and witnesses having to lose pay by taking time off from their jobs. Robert J. Fall Age: 44; McCandless EDUCATION: B.S., St. Joseph’s College, Indiana; J.D., Ohio Northern University. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Nineteen years experience in jury and non-jury trials, especially family and civil divisions; appointed arbitrator in civil division; argued cases in Pennsylvania appellate courts; "recommended" by bar association; firefighter in McCandless; volunteer at Terrors-by-the-Lake Haunted House, benefiting Make-a-Wish Foundation. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Taxpayers deserve hard-working, efficient judges. I respect the time parties, witnesses and jurors sacrifice from their daily lives. I advocate judges handling cases from beginning to end. This provides thorough knowledge of the issues, avoiding duplication when different judges must review the entire case each time a new issue is presented. The parties benefit because it exposes abuse of the system by frivolous maneuvers. The result should be prompt decisions with individual, personal attention to each case.
Democrat
Frank Salpietro Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" David K. McMullin Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Louis C. Coles Age: 46; Hill District EDUCATION: B.A., University of Pennsylvania; J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: City of Pittsburgh magistrate. QUALIFICATIONS: Twenty years of practice in all divisions of the state courts. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Elect more black officials to elective office so that a minority opinion and sensibility are felt in the administration of the laws of the Commonwealth. Eugene G. Berry Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Jacqueline Morrow Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Beth Williams Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Kathleen Anne Cribbins Age: 42; Ross EDUCATION: B.A., J.D., University of Pittsburgh. OCCUPATION: Attorney - public defender. QUALIFICATIONS: Recommended by the bar association; chairman of arbitration panels in the civil division; extensive experience in litigation including death penalty, homicide, child abuse and custody cases; experience in all divisions of the court. ANSWER TO QUESTION: A people-oriented system for hearing certain cases within a short time after filing would result in speedier decisions on child support, homeowners’ disputes with contractors, custody, adoptions and criminal cases. Cases requiring extensive investigation could be listed as complex cases and scheduled for later dates. The use of multiple rooms for jury selection would allow juries to be selected more quickly. Introducing all young people to actual trials and sentencings could reduce crime. Robert J. Fall Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Richard W. Stec No Reply James E. Mahood Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Timothy E. Finnerty Age: 51; Churchill EDUCATION: University of Pittsburgh, Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Trial Attorney, manager of Labor Relations -- County of Allegheny. QUALIFICATIONS: Twenty-two years of trial experience in all areas of the law and all divisions of the Court of Common Pleas and in the U.S. District Court of Western Pennsylvania. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Resolving the conflict between expedited litigation/conflict resolution and the right of every citizen to a full and fair hearing on their claims is the major problem with our legal system. Having the parties limit the issue and instituting expedited procedures for resolution of the defining issue in cases would be a way of cutting off the numerous irrelevant fishing expeditions of the litigants and their counsel. Kevin G. Sasinoski Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Lynn MacBeth Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Randy Todd Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Falco A. Muscante Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Charles Timothy Clark Age: 39; Harrison Township EDUCATION: B.S., Indiana University of Pennsylvania; J.D., Duquesne University. OCCUPATION: Attorney, public defender. QUALIFICATIONS: Having practiced in every division of the Allegheny County Courts and virtually every District Court, I possess the understanding of the scope/need for efficient, hard-working and dedicated justice. ANSWER TO QUESTION: To improve the administration of justice in Allegheny County, foremost it is essential to have a full complement of judges on the bench. Combine this with continued dedication and a vigorous work ethic and the judiciary will augment its function in the administration of justice. In the criminal courts it is essential that both the prosecution and public defenders offices be fully funded and staffed. Only then will victims and defendants enjoy full and speedy justice. Jerry DeRiso Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Phil Melograne Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" William T. Simmons Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Gayle Godfrey Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Kevin J. Flaherty Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Joseph C. Farina Age: 47; Wilkinsburg EDUCATION: B.A., Michigan State University; J.D. Thomas Cooley Law School (Lansing, Michigan). OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Twenty years experience practicing law including litigation of cases involving personal injury, contract interpretation and domestic relations; I am patient and even tempered and will treat all parties fairly. ANSWER TO QUESTION: All claims filed in the Civil Division where the amount in controversy is $50,000 or less should be submitted to compulsory arbitration. The Arbitration Division is an efficient and convenient forum for such cases and judicial resources should be devoted to larger, more complicated claims. An early status conference should be held in cases on the General Docket to explore settlement potential, the possibility of alternative dispute resolution or need for parameters on discovery. Mike McCarthy Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" David J. DeFazio Age: 44; Shaler EDUCATION: B.S., La Roche College; J.D., Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Trial Attorney; university instructor at University of Pittsburgh GSPIA. QUALIFICATIONS: Extensive trial experience based upon working at Allegheny County District Attorney’s office and private practice; I have successfully litigated cases from disorderly conduct through homicide. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Courts must balance the need to dispose of the enormous amount of cases that appear on their docket, while at the same time giving each party their day in court. Many times, judges compete with each other over the attorneys, police witnesses and prosecutors who are scheduled in many court rooms at the same time. I would try to be more proactive in coordinating my docket with the schedules of the other judges and attorneys. Moira Harrington Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Ruth A. Zittrain Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Phillip T. Cheswick EDUCATION: B.A., University of Pittsburgh, J.D.; Duquesne University Law School. OCCUPATION: Attorney and owner of five-member law firm; retired Pittsburgh police lieutenant. QUALIFICATIONS: Extensive trial and hearing experience over 20 year legal practice, plus trial experience as police prosecutor in 23 year police career covering all aspects of criminal justice system. ANSWER TO QUESTION: The Common Pleas Court of Allegheny County although efficient in view of the number of cases which it is able to resolve, would benefit from individual judge’s calendar control where witnesses, jurors and law enforcement would have specific times in which they would appear and the case heard immediately. This, along with the federal system of attorney pre-trial status conferences and conciliations, would move the cases through the court with greater efficiency and speed. Kim Diane Eaton Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Carol Lynn Hanna Age: 47; Bethel Park EDUCATION: B.A., J.D., Duquesne University. OCCUPATION: Attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Proficient in general state law practice; experienced in state appellate practice; good judicial temperament ANSWER TO QUESTION: Stricter adherence to time schedules; more accountability for being reversed on appeal to promote diligence and honesty. Frank Dermody No Reply Wrenna Leigh Watson Age: 45; Hill District EDUCATION: Duquesne University, J.D., Howard University. OCCUPATION: Hearing officer, attorney. QUALIFICATIONS: Fourteen years service in courts; six years hearing officer/judge, adjudicated over 4,500 cases; eight years serving judges, in courtroom/chambers learning to judge/adjudicate; know court system, served as hearing officer, attorney, law clerk, tipstaff, probation officer. ANSWER TO QUESTION: Decrease time spent in court waiting so that children miss less school/adults less work because of hearings and continuances. Adopt attitude-doing whatever is required: working until cases are completed daily, coordinating schedules of timed hearings. Start early and work through lunch if necessary. Increase number of judges lessening the caseload and taking advantage of PA legislature’s allotment granting five additional judges to Allegheny County. Terry McVerry Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Guido A. DeAngelis Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Susan Ruffner Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Gene Scanlon Jr. Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Catherine A. Conley Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Daniel L. Sautel Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Ronda Winnecour Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Daniel Sean McIntyre Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Frank J. Lucchino Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Dan Butler Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Frank Cecchetti Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Bob Colville Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" Christine S. McCrady No Reply Mark R. Tamilia No Reply Bonnie Brimmeier Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican" James E. Durkin Cross-filed; see listing in "Republican"
|
