My engagement in the health
and medical care activity in Pittsburgh is related to the view I have of this community,
which is broader than health and medical care. I believe Pittsburgh is a good place with a
potential to be a great place, but I dont think it is a great place yet. In order
for us to be a great place, we need to select the areas where we have a prospect of being
great because we have a good foundation to work from.
In education, I think we have the makings of a great system. At the higher education
level, we have real distinction at Carnegie Mellon, UPMC and the University of Pittsburgh.
Many of the programs are really first rate. I think we are not as great at the elementary
levels.
In the health and medical area, we have many elements of greatness but we are not truly
great. I believe it is possible for us to do some things that would be good for the whole
community and that would demonstrate to the whole nation that there is a different way to
think about the problems in health and medical care -- by focusing on being a place of
best practices.
According to the best national studies, there are 185,000 human beings in the United
States killed every year by medical mistakes. To put that in context, thats two
Egyptian airliners every day going down. Because it only happens to one individual at a
time, we dont pay a lot of attention to it, and we dont really see it. But
that study said 185,000 -- thats a lot.
The error rate in the best studies is one in 2,000. Think about that. Some of you would
know about the idea of six sigma. There are a lot of industries that say, "We are in
a six sigma industry." That means you are only permitted to make 3.4 errors per
million exposures. One in 2,000 is 500 per million. Its no sigma.
I think in Pittsburgh we can create a community resolve to be a learning laboratory for
the nation. And we can make it a matter of community purpose to say that we are going to
demonstrate that we can eliminate medication errors in all of southwestern Pennsylvania.
And we can eliminate staph infections. Those infections are a serious cause of extended
and more costly hospital stays for patients who contract an infection through no fault of
their own, but because of the way medicine is practiced.
Maybe we can add to that that we are going to eliminate accidents that happen to
medical staff. One of the routine ones is for people to stick themselves with a hypodermic
needle and get an infection.
We can do this, and it will require a very substantial change in the system of delivery
of medical care. It will require using electronic technology to the level that we already
use it in banks. Believe it or not, we could use it in medical care. So that you could
capture data about a patients radiology and admission and all the rest just by
effectively using your plastic card to download data to any doctor you want to.
We already have the capability to do all of these things. My notion is that we can get
the community leaders, in a very broad-based sense, to agree that we will be a learning
laboratory and that we can be on our way to achieving what I think is possible for the
country -- an improvement in the value equation of heath and medical care of something
between 35 and 50 percent. That means either twice as much care available or half the
current costs.
Those are doable things, and if we together dont do something in that direction,
we are going to continue to be the victim of well-intentioned, fiddling-with-reimbursement
formulas that dont accomplish anything except drive the provider community crazy and
interfere in decisions that ought to be made by people with professional training.
Were not too far away from having an agreement that we are going to try to do
this. That we can do something in Pittsburgh that will show the rest of the nation how we
can do a job that is worthy of an intelligent society, instead of continually arguing and
debating issues that go nowhere.
All of the arguments in the current debate on medical and health care are so
well-learned. Most of the participants can recite their part of the argument in their
sleep. And its not only boring, its counterproductive as hell. There is a
better way, and we here in Pittsburgh have a chance to show the whole nation how to do it
better.