
Economic party's on tap
By Paul R. Flora, Post-Gazette Associate Editor
When economists forecasts go awry, they usually prefer to
be caught short - where the actual economy grows faster and produces more jobs than
expected. Its easier to explain away the differences with good news in hand.
But the economists surveyed last year for the inaugural forecast edition of PG
Benchmarks have nothing to worry about on either count. Their predictions for 1998 were
mostly on target. And the small differences that were revealed by events or by measurement
error were all to the good.
So this year we bring them all back to recount what went right with the economy last
year, and what they expect for 1999 with a peek at the next millennium. Well, almost all
of them. Mellon Banks economics department disbanded earlier this year, scuttling
one of this regions few local sources for short-term economic forecasts.
Looking back, our panel of economists agree that the global economic crisis which
struck Brazil, Russia and much of Asia had less negative impact on the U.S. economy than
was expected, so far. And our domestic market was further buoyed by the resurgence in
stocks.
In large part, they credit the Federal Reserve, which responded last fall to global
problems with easier monetary policy. The Feds actions lowered interest rates,
stimulating domestic growth, while also shoring up Asian currencies and their economies by
making dollars relatively less attractive to hold than yen.
So national economic growth continued unabated in 1998 - its 3.9 percent increase of
real gross domestic product defied these forecasters early average expectation of a
more temperate 2.9 percent pace of growth. More job growth was also generated - 2.6
percent rather than the 2.2 percent average predicted nationally. And that was sufficient
for the U.S. unemployment rate to edge lower to 4.5 percent.
As goes the nation, so goes the region. Job growth of 1.5 percent for the Pittsburgh
metro area exceeded the average forecast of 1.2 percent and trimmed one percentage point
from the 4.7 percent average forecast for the regions unemployment rate. Whos
going to complain about those near misses? In fact, last seasons forecasts,
especially for the re gion, are deemed quite accurate.
Looking forward, these same forecasters anticipate nearly as much economic growth as
last year. And while a slight slowdown is indicated for U.S. output and job growth, the
increased economic activity appears to be sufficient to drive unemployment rates lower,
regionally and nationally. Reasons for optimism, cited by Stuart Hoffman, chief economist
at PNC Bank, include low inflation, a growing federal budget surplus, confident consumers,
the rebound in many key stock indices, a strong dollar and affordable interest rates.
Hoffman also lists several potential risks that could hamper growth in 1999, led by an
international environment in which several countries remain in recession while others are
flirting with one. Even as the most troubled Asian economies begin to stabilize, growth in
Europe has begun to stall.
The millennium bugs threat to incapacitate computer systems throughout the world,
creating physical and economic calamity, appears diminished. But the fear may slightly
whipsaw economies, as spending shrivels in the first quarter of 2000 in contrast to
increased purchases of pre-millennium fixes and stockpiled supplies in the waning days of
this century.
An increasingly tight labor market and high levels of personal debt complete
Hoffmans short list of negative factors facing the nations economy. None is
expected to trigger a U.S. recession this year.
Propelled by the ongoing national expansion and the increase in local construction
projects, including the convention center, stadiums, highways and various private Downtown
office expansions, Hoffman expects Pittsburghs economy to pick up speed in 1999.
After posting the lowest forecast for Pittsburghs job growth in 1998, PNC Bank is
out front with a prediction of 1.7 percent job growth for 1999.
In contrast, RFA, a Philadelphia-based economic research firm, sported the highest, and
presumably most accurate, forecast last year for the regions job growth, but
anticipates that growth will slow to 1.0 percent this year.
However, economists often place probabilities on several alternative outcomes. And Mark
Zandi, RFAs chief economist, feels theres a better chance that 1999 could turn
out better, rather than worse, than RFAs 1999 Pittsburgh forecast suggests.
The relatively rapid adjustment of Pittsburghs economic base to one driven by
technology and information is viewed by Zandi as an overriding strength for this region.
But he sees a high cost structure for production-oriented business as a key disadvantage
for the region that drives many to move south, west or overseas. In particular, one of the
hallmarks of the current economy is that businesses cant raise prices, so moving
becomes a way to cut costs and raise profits.

Despite the risks from failing foreign economies and the escalating war in Eastern
Europe, odds are good that the U.S. economy will grow into the next millennium, and
beyond. Economists, known for conservative forecasts rather than for frivolity, all point
to a recession-free 1999, which would almost guarantee a record-setting expansion will
follow in February, 2000.
The record for the longest U.S. economic expansion - dating back to 1854 - is 106
months, which spanned Feb. 1961 to Dec. 1969. The current expansion, which began in March
1991, is all the more remarkable given that it follows on the heels of the nations
third longest expansion (Nov. 1982 to July 1990).
In general, recessions have grown shorter and expansions longer during this century.
Recessions during the first third of this century averaged 20 months (including the Great
Depression), expansions averaged 26 months. Since then, the duration of recessions has
been trimmed to about 10 months, while expansions lengthened to 45 months during the
40s and 50s, then 67 months, and counting, since 1961.
Economic expansions need not die of old age. And federal policy
appears more effective in maintaining a stable economic environment. While the economy
could swoon from a sudden lack of confidence, the current economy is sound and is expected
to survive the hazards it faces in 1999.

Return to
Index Page
|