Scarlett Johansson, Oxfam part ways over politics

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

JERUSALEM -- Scarlett Johansson has parted ways with the international charity Oxfam because of a dispute over her work for SodaStream, a company operating in a West Bank settlement that features the Hollywood star in an ad that will air during the Super Bowl.

Ms. Johansson became the latest casualty of a widening campaign to boycott the settlements, drawing attention to a larger debate about whether Israel will become an international pariah, at a steep economic price, if it fails to reach a peace deal with the Palestinians.

Israeli Finance Minister Yair Lapid stoked such fears this week, warning that if negotiations break down, "and we enter a reality of a European boycott -- even a very partial one -- Israel's economy will retreat backward, and every Israeli citizen will feel it straight in the pocket."

His comments reflected a growing sense in Israel that the coming weeks will be decisive for the country's future. U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry is formulating ideas for an Israeli-Palestinian framework agreement and is expected to present them next month. Israeli and Palestinian leaders have balked at some of his expected proposals and, if they stick to their positions, could derail what is widely seen as a last chance for ending a long-festering conflict.

Meanwhile, European officials have warned that Israel could face deepening economic isolation if it presses forward with construction of settlements in the West Bank and east Jerusalem, war-won lands the Palestinians want for their state. The fate of dozens of settlements, home to 550,000 Israelis, is a key sticking point in the talks.

Ms. Johansson, 29, stepped into that controversy this month, when she agreed to become a global brand ambassador for SodaStream, a Tel Aviv-based company that makes home soda machines and has its main plant in an Israeli industrial park next to the West Bank settlement of Maaleh Adumim. The actress, nominated four times for a Golden Globe, is to appear in a SodaStream ad during Sunday's Super Bowl telecast.

Her decision riled Oxfam International, a humanitarian aid organization for which she had served as global ambassador for eight years, helping raise donations for victims of natural disasters in Indonesia and the Philippines, among other causes.

Ms. Johansson said in a statement Wednesday that she was stepping down from that role, citing a "fundamental difference of opinion" with Oxfam. The actress, whose movies over the past two years include "The Avengers" and "Her," said she supports economic cooperation between "a democratic Israel and Palestine."

Oxfam accepted her resignation Thursday. The organization said it believes that SodaStream and other businesses operating in West Bank settlements contribute to the "denial of rights of the Palestinian communities that we work to support." The charity said it opposes all trade with Israeli settlements, deemed illegal by most of the international community.

Ms. Johansson was one of 17 celebrity ambassadors for Oxfam. Others who are continuing in that role include the band Coldplay, pop singer Annie Lennox and actress Kristin Davis of "Sex and the City" fame, the organization said. Ms. Davis was involved in a similar controversy as Ms. Johansson. Ms. Davis stepped away from her Oxfam duties while appearing in ads for Ahava, a cosmetics firm that manufactures in a West Bank settlement, but then returned to the charity.

The Palestinian-led campaign for boycott, divestment and sanctions -- known as BDS -- on Thursday welcomed the controversy surrounding Ms. Johansson, though she decided to stay with SodaStream. "Without doubt, the biggest loser in this well-publicized BDS campaign was SodaStream, which was exposed to the whole world as an occupation profiteer," said Omar Barghouti, a leader of the movement founded in 2005 by Palestinian grass-roots activists.

The BDS campaign has won support from activists around the globe, and recently scored a number of successes. A small but growing number of European businesses and pension funds have dropped investments or limited trade with Israeli firms with West Bank settlement ties.

Some BDS activists focus on a boycott of settlements, while others saying everything Israeli must be shunned until there is a peace deal. BDS supporters argue that Israel will withdraw from war-won lands only if it pays a price for continuing the occupation. Israeli leaders dismiss such claims, pointing to their willingness to negotiate a land-for-peace deal with the Palestinians.

In an interview Wednesday, SodaStream's chief executive, Dan Birnbaum, shrugged off the boycott campaign. "To the best of my knowledge, we have not lost a single customer. If anything, it advances our awareness around the world, because people are talking about SodaStream," he said, adding that the company doesn't want to "sacrifice" the jobs of 500 Palestinians who work in its factory "for some political cause" of activist groups.

Ms. Johansson was chastised by some, praised by others.

Mr. Barghouti said in a statement that she "reminds us of the few unprincipled artists who during the struggle against South African apartheid sold their souls and stood on the wrong side of history." But the World Jewish Congress praised her as "a role model for others confronted with insidious anti-Israeli pressure."

A call placed Thursday to Ms. Johansson's representative was not immediately returned.

In Israel, the potential danger of a widening boycott, once dismissed as a fringe issue, is increasingly taking center stage in public debate. The Israeli Treasury has examined various scenarios, and Mr. Lapid, the finance minister, said the results are worrying. Even in the case of a limited boycott that cuts Israeli exports to the European Union by 20 percent, he said, damage would amount to about $5.7 billion in exports annually.

Israel's GDP -- just under $260 billion in 2011, according to the World Bank -- would lose about $3 billion each year, he told a high-profile security conference in Tel Aviv late Wednesday.

Intelligence Minister Yuval Steinitz from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's hard-line Likud Party played down the risks, saying Israel "has the tools to prevent boycotts." He did not elaborate.

Mr. Steinitz, a former finance minister, told Israel Radio on Thursday that any deal that endangers Israel's security would do far more economic damage than a boycott.

Join the conversation:

Commenting policy | How to report abuse
To report inappropriate comments, abuse and/or repeat offenders, please send an email to and include a link to the article and a copy of the comment. Your report will be reviewed in a timely manner. Thank you.
Commenting policy | How to report abuse


You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here