An Industry Struggles to Keep Its Luster

Share with others:


Print Email Read Later

ANTWERP, Belgium -- Step off the train here and you cannot miss the signs on the stores: Diamond World, Diamond Gallery, Diamond Creations or simply, Diamonds. Of late, there are the banners and posters reading simply, "Antwerp Loves Diamonds."

Though this Belgian port has had a love affair with diamonds for centuries, of late it seems to be losing some of its passion. For years now, much of the lucrative but labor-intensive business of cutting and polishing stones has been drifting to low-wage centers in the developing world, like Mumbai, Dubai and Shanghai.

More ominously, in recent years, diamond traders have been accused of a range of violations, including tax fraud, money laundering and cheating on customs payments when buying and selling stones.

Local business leaders recognize the threat. This year, they embarked on what local newspapers described as a "charm offensive." In a 160-page program, titled Project 2020, the World Diamond Center, a trade-promotion group, outlined plans to draw business back to Antwerp by simplifying and accelerating trading via online systems. That, the industry hopes, will win back some of the polishing business lost to Asian countries with new technology, like fully automated diamond polishers, and generally burnish the image of the diamond business in the public's jaded eye.

"This is our strength," said Ari Epstein, 36, a lawyer who is chief executive of the World Diamond Center and the son of a diamond trader, whose father emigrated from a village in Romania in the 1960s. "We have the critical mass so that every diamond finds a buyer and seller."

Antwerp has by no means fallen out of love with the gems. In all, the market employs 8,000 people and creates work indirectly for 26,000 others as insurers, bankers, security guards and drivers. Last year, turnover in the local diamond business amounted to $56 billion, Mr. Epstein said, its best year ever.

While total revenues are expected to drop this year because of the troubled world economy, he acknowledged, a stroll along Hoveniersstraat, or Gardner's Street, leads through the heart of the market, where almost 85 percent of the world's uncut diamonds are still traded.

"I come here once a month," said Sheh Kamliss, a trader in his 30s, who travels from his native India to buy uncut stones and sell polished diamonds. "This is the international market," he added, chatting with fellow Indian traders outside the Diamond Club of Antwerp, one of many locations where deals are struck.

On any given day but Friday or the Jewish holidays, Hoveniersstraat, with its tiny Sephardic synagogue, is liberally sprinkled with Orthodox Jewish traders, many of them Hasidim.

But their once dominant presence has been squeezed by the arrival of traders from new markets, like Mr. Kamliss. Now people from about 70 nations are present, including Indians, Israelis, Lebanese, Russians, Chinese and others. Along neighboring Lange Herentalsestraat, Rachel's Kosher Restaurant is now flanked by the Bollywood Indian Restaurant and the Shanti Shop Indian supermarket. In the nearby Jewish quarter, Patel's Cash & Carry recently installed itself right next to Moszkowitz, the butcher.

Some here say this globalization of the business has opened the door to abuse.

Omega Diamonds, a major market maker, came under investigation and its executives fled Belgium when an employee-turned-whistle-blower revealed in 2006 how Omega had traded diamonds out of Africa for years, avoiding taxes by transacting deals through Dubai, Tel Aviv and Geneva, then moving the profits back to Belgium.

"Because of global changes, the trade routes have changed," said David Renous, 47, the whistle blower, who is now writing a book on the subject. "New hubs, like Dubai, the Singapore of the Middle East, sometimes close their eyes to criminality."

A year earlier, in 2005, an Antwerp-based courier business, Monstrey Worldwide Services, which once had a near monopoly on diamond deliveries, was alleged to have misused customs-free zones in places like Geneva to smuggle stones. More recently, in 2009, investigations into possible tax evasion were begun regarding hundreds of diamond dealers, including many in Antwerp, named on lists of account holders at the Swiss branch of the British HSBC bank. Last year, similar inquiries were opened in India and in Antwerp after WikiLeaks provided the authorities with lists of Indian citizens, including dozens of diamond traders, holding Swiss bank accounts.

None of these investigations have led to trials in Antwerp, much less convictions.

Antwerp's prosecutors, said Alex Kestens, who has covered the cases for the Gazet van Antwerpen, the city's leading paper, "are slowest when diamonds are involved," for fear of tarnishing Antwerp's diamond business.

Indeed, in recent months there have been headlines about a struggle between a junior prosecutor, Peter Van Calster, who has pushed for more aggressive investigations, and his superior, Yves Liégeois, who sought to sideline Mr. Van Calster by bringing charges against him for alleged investigative errors. Mr. Van Calster is suing his boss in Belgium's highest administrative court, in the capital Brussels.

"It's a dirty war; everyone thought Van Calster was dead," Mr. Kestens said. "It's David against Goliath, and behind Goliath are other judges and politicians."

Some in the diamond industry, like Mr. Epstein, get annoyed with the investigative foot-dragging, which serves only to keep diamonds in the negative headlines. "We think people should pay taxes on profits, let that be clear," he said, arguing that, "we are the most transparent diamond trading center in the world."

"That said," he added, "as far as cases like HSBC are concerned, what needs to be done needs to be done rapidly."

Down the street from Mr. Epstein's offices, Danny Meylemans, 39, a fourth-generation diamond polisher, battles on the front most vulnerable to foreign encroachment. "In Antwerp we have a few hundred polishers," he said. "In the late '60s there were over 20,000." Yet Antwerp's future lies not just in diamond trading, he insisted, but in cutting and polishing, too, if it focuses on the high end of the market.

"We still have the knowledge, the know-how, the patience, to work on difficult and very expensive stones," he said. "More than half of my customers are Indian."

Others, too, believe that the fear of diamonds deserting Antwerp is exaggerated. Mr. Renous, the former diamond trader, is a native of Belgium with Israeli citizenship who has also spent years in Africa and Southeast Asia. He has a passion for Antwerp, he said, that many diamond traders share. They begin by visiting occasionally for business, he said, but wind up settling here with their families for the good food, proximity to places like Amsterdam, London or Paris, and the comfortable living.

"No one's leaving," he said, "to go to Dubai, Mumbai, or even Tel Aviv."

world

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.


Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here