House GOP votes to sue Obama

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

WASHINGTON — House Republicans voted Wednesday to proceed with a lawsuit against President Barack Obama, saying his executive actions are so extreme that they violate the Constitution.

The nearly party-line vote — all Democrats voted against it, and all but five Republicans voted for it — further agitated an already-polarized climate on Capitol Hill, as both parties used the pending suit to try to rally support ahead of the November elections.

Halfway across the continent, Mr. Obama almost gloated at the prospect of being sued. “They’re going to sue me for taking executive actions to help people. So they’re mad I’m doing my job,” he said in an economics speech in Kansas City, Mo. “And by the way, I’ve told them I’d be happy to do it [take action] with you. The only reason I’m doing it on my own is because you’re not doing anything,” he said of Congress.

The clash came a day before Congress is scheduled to begin a 5 1/​2-week summer break, and as must-pass bills on reshaping veterans’ health care and highway construction appeared headed for passage — while most everything else was not. For instance, the House and Senate moved in dramatically different directions on legislation designed to deal with the flow of thousands of unaccompanied Central American minors arriving at the border.

Expecting a flurry of work once the elections are over in November, leaders in both parties have instead tried to position their rank-and-file to take advantage of the gridlock by blaming the other side. By the time this year concludes, the 113th Congress is all but assured of being the least productive in recorded history in terms of producing legislation signed into law.

The details of House Speaker John Boehner’s lawsuit mattered little — it focuses on a narrow portion of the landmark health care law — and instead each side focused on the larger symbolism of the moment.

Democrats linked the lawsuit to calls from outspoken conservative activists urging the impeachment of Mr. Obama, a battle cry that Democrats have amplified in an effort to raise money and get people to vote. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., glaring at Republicans during the heated debate, accused Mr. Boehner, R-Ohio, of caving into “impeachment-hungry extremists.”

“Tell them impeachment is off the table. That’s what I had to do,” she said, noting several attempts by liberals to impeach former President George W. Bush and former Vice President Dick Cheney while she was House speaker.

Mr. Boehner, who has repeatedly said impeachment is not in the cards, connected the suit to a series of executive orders that Mr. Obama issued on climate change, immigration rules, the health care law and raising the minimum wage for federal contractors, saying those were power grabs that did not have requisite backing from Congress. “Are you willing to let anyone tear apart what our founders built?” Mr. Boehner asked during debate.

The lawsuit is the culmination of heightened conflict since Mr. Obama took office in 2009, particularly since Mr. Boehner became speaker more than three years ago. It is also unprecedented in its nature. Plenty of congressmen, of both parties, have filed lawsuits or briefs in support of suits against presidents. Generally, federal judges dismiss the cases because usually only those affected by the law had standing to file suit.

If the federal courts take up the matter, it could take years to reach conclusion and may have a larger impact on setting the parameters of the balance between the next president and Congress. The short-term impact will be the political jockeying in the next three months. Democrats said the lawsuit would turn off middle-of-the-road voters who begin to make up their minds in late summer and early fall, suggesting that it would distract from the economic issues that Republicans hope to focus on.

“They are limping into August, wrestling with themselves over impeachment, and being criticized for suing the president, instead of addressing issues that matter to the middle class. This is not the August recess that they anticipated,” New York Rep. Steve Israel, the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee chairman, said in an interview. In a four-day span after a top Obama adviser said he took the threat of impeachment seriously, the DCCC sent a flurry of fundraising pitches and brought in more than $2 million.

In the floor debate, the two sides clashed in the sharpest of terms. Republicans passionately defended the lawsuit as a way to protect Congress from executive overreach. “I believe in this institution,” said Rep. Richard Nugent, R-Fla. “I believe in the Constitution.”

Democrat after Democrat focused remarks on impeachment, which they said would be the logical outcome of a lawsuit asking the courts to say Mr. Obama had violated the Constitution. New York Rep. Louise Slaughter, ranking Democrat on the Rules Committee, called it a “monumental waste of time, energy and funds” that was designed only to encourage conservative voters to back Republicans this fall.


You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here