Prosecutor says Texas drunk driver did not deserve ‘execution’

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

ANGLETON, Tex. — A drunken driver did not de­serve “ex­e­cu­tion” by a Texas father ac­cused of tak­ing the law into his own hands in a fit of rage over the kill­ing of his two sons in a wreck, a pros­e­cu­tor told ju­rors Tues­day.

David Bara­jas is ac­cused of fa­tally shoot­ing Jose Banda in Decem­ber 2012, min­utes af­ter Mr. Banda plowed into a pickup truck that Mr. Bara­jas and his two sons had been push­ing on a ru­ral road. Twelve-year-old David Jr. died at the scene, and 11-year-old Caleb died at a hos­pi­tal. Mr. Bara­jas’ truck had run out of gas about 100 yards from the fam­ily’s home.

Mr. Bara­jas’ at­tor­ney told ju­rors that his cli­ent did not kill Mr. Banda, and that he was fo­cused only on sav­ing his sons.

In open­ing state­ments Tues­day in Mr. Bara­jas’ mur­der trial, pros­e­cu­tor Brian Hrach told ju­rors Mr. Banda made a hor­ri­ble de­ci­sion by drink­ing and driv­ing, “He de­served se­vere le­gal pun­ish­ment, but he did not de­serve a pub­lic ex­e­cu­tion,” Mr. Hrach said.

Mr. Bara­jas al­leg­edly left the ac­ci­dent scene, re­trieved a gun from his home and re­turned to kill Mr. Banda.

Sam Cam­mack, Mr. Bara­jas’ at­tor­ney, told ju­rors that his cli­ent never left the crash site. Mr. Cam­mack por­trayed Mr. Bara­jas as a father who was des­per­ate to help his sons and was cov­ered with their blood af­ter he tried to per­form CPR on the boys. “When po­lice get there, my cli­ent is do­ing what he was do­ing the whole time, try­ing to save his chil­dren’s lives,” the at­tor­ney said.

Dash­cam video of the crash scene played for ju­rors Tues­day af­ter tes­ti­mony had be­gun brought many in the court­room to tears. Mr. Bara­jas kept his head down as the video was played. On the video, Mr. Bara­jas can be seen kneel­ing on the ground near a road­side ditch where the body of his son David Jr. had landed. A woman can be heard scream­ing, “My ba­bies. Why? Oh, my God, please help them.” David Bara­jas’ wife, Cindy, and their in­fant son and 8-year-old daugh­ter had also been in the truck. They were not se­ri­ously hurt.

Legal ex­perts said the case will be dif­fi­cult to pros­e­cute given the lack of hard ev­i­dence: No weapon was re­cov­ered, no wit­nesses iden­ti­fied Mr. Bara­jas as the shooter, and gun­shot res­i­due tests done on Mr. Bara­jas were neg­a­tive. The trial is in the county seat of An­gle­ton, Tex.

On one call, scream­ing can be heard in the back­ground, as an un­iden­ti­fied caller told a dis­patcher that a boy is “bleed­ing badly, ... he’s in half. It’s bad.” On an­other call, an un­iden­ti­fied caller said, “There is a guy shoot­ing at peo­ple.” The per­son who was shoot­ing was not iden­ti­fied.

Mr. Cam­mack high­lighted for ju­rors the time­line, while ques­tion­ing dis­patcher Grace Gambino. The first 911 call came in at 11:33 p.m., a child was re­ported dead at 11:34 p.m., gun­shots were heard at 11:35 p.m., and po­lice had ar­rived at the scene and cleared it for EMS to come in at 11:40 p.m.

If con­victed, Mr. Bara­jas faces as much as life in prison. Tes­ti­mony was to re­sume to­day. At least 25 fam­ily mem­bers and friends of Mr. Bara­jas were in the court­room, wear­ing but­tons that said, “For­ever in our hearts, David and Caleb Bara­jas” with a pic­ture of the two boys. At least 20 rel­a­tives and friends of Mr. Banda were also in the court­room.

United States - North America - Texas


You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here