Retailers have broad authority on shoplifting

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

NEW YORK -- Outside the view of paying customers, people accused of shoplifting at Macy's huge flagship store are escorted by security guards to cells in "Room 140," where they can be held for hours, asked to sign an admission of guilt and pay hundreds in fines -- sometimes without any conclusive proof that they stole anything.

As shoppers jam stores ahead of the December holidays, claims of racial profiling at New York department stores have helped expose the wide latitude that laws in at least 27 states give retailers to hold and fine shoplifting suspects, even if a person hasn't yet technically stolen anything, is wrongly accused or criminal charges are dropped.

"You must remember, these people are not police officers; they are store employees," said Faruk Usar, the attorney for a 62-year-old Turkish woman who sued Macy's, which some customers say bullied them into paying fines on the spot or harassed them with letters demanding payment. "When they are detained, they are not yet even in a real jail."

Industrywide, more than $12 billion a year is lost to shoplifting. The laws, which vary on strictness and fine amounts, allow stores to try to recoup some losses

Under New York's longstanding law, retailers may collect a penalty of five times the cost of the stolen merchandise, as much as $500 per item, plus as much as $1,500 if the merchandise isn't in a condition to be sold. A conviction is not necessary to bring a civil claim. Some customers say stores have harassed them into signing admissions of guilt in order to turn a profit -- not just recoup a loss.

Retailers don't divulge how much money they recoup, but they use it in part to offset security costs, said Barbara Staib, spokeswoman for the National Association for Shoplifting Prevention. The total is a fraction of what they lose, she said. "We tend to forget that retailers are the victims of crime when it comes to shoplifting," Ms. Staib said.

But at least nine customers at the Macy's store immortalized in "Miracle on 34th Street" say in lawsuits that the retailer is abusing the law.


You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here