Research finds red meat linked with Type 2 diabetes

The Fourth of July has become a holiday of fireworks and gluttonous meat consumption. But this year's protein packdown comes with notes of caution.

Red and processed meats that have been linked with heart disease and cancer now may be a major factor with another disease that's epidemic in the United States -- Type 2 diabetes.

The American Meat Institute, a national trade association that represents packers and processors of meat and poultry products, says 150 million hot dogs will be eaten on this week's holiday, and that, if placed end to end, the dogs would extend from New York City to Los Angeles nearly six times, or more than halfway around the world.

Science already has identified red meats -- beef, lamb and pork -- and processed meats as contributors to cardiovascular disease, including heart attacks and strokes, as well as colon cancer. But a recent study by the Harvard School of Public Health says a new look at the 123,000 people involved in a 20-year study ending in 2006 found elevated red-meat consumption to be linked with an increase in diabetes.

In Type 2 diabetes, either the body does not produce enough insulin or cells resist the effects of insulin, which is necessary for the body to be able to use glucose for energy.

According to the study, increased red meat intake in a four-year period resulted in increased diabetes in the following four years. When compared with a group with no change in red meat intake, the study showed that increasing red meat intake of more than a half-serving a day -- equivalent to half the size of a deck of cards -- for four years was associated with a 48 percent elevated risk of diabetes in the subsequent four years.

The opposite also was true. When meat consumption was reduced by more than a half serving per day, risk dropped, states the study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, Internal Medicine last month.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture characterizes meat from mammals as red meat, with poultry and fish described as white.

"The association of red meat and cardiovascular disease are quite clear," said Walter C. Willett, Harvard School of Public Health's chairman of the department of nutrition. "It does look as though replacing red meats with other major sources of quality protein -- nuts, legumes, chicken and fish -- is a good thing to be doing."

Iron, long heralded as a key nutritional attribute of red meat, might represent the hazardous link between red meat and Type 2 diabetes.

Heme iron from red meat is absorbed even if the person already has sufficient stores of the mineral. Nonheme iron from plants is expelled from the body once the person has a sufficient supply. "Our bodies don't regulate heme iron well, and it can damage cells that secrete insulin," Dr. Willett said. "That may be part of it."

Processed meats often involving beef and pork contain more sodium, preservatives and sometimes nitrates that, he said, "cause chemical reactions that may create compounds that are toxic."

"Processed meat is a complex area, with different amounts of constituents," Dr. Willett said. "It's a murky stew."

For perspective, Dr. Willett said, one's state of health isn't defined by what one eats on a particular day of the year. He said he occasionally eats red meat but mostly sticks with chicken and fish.

But the American Meat Institute disagrees with the study's results and countered "that meat is a nutritious part of a healthy balanced diet."

"While some recent studies have generated headlines linking meat to different ailments, it is important to remember that conditions like heart disease, cancer and diabetes are complex conditions that cannot simply be caused by any one food," institute spokesman Eric Mittenthal said.

A deeper look at the diabetes study, he said, shows data were gathered through questionnaires about eating habits every four years. "This imprecise approach is like relying on [consumers'] personal characterization of their driving habits in prior years to determine their likelihood of having an accident that kills them in the future," he said. "It has a high likelihood of giving erroneous conclusions."

Evidence and common sense, he said, suggest that "a balanced diet and a healthy body weight are the keys to good health."

C. Colin Campbell, Cornell University professor emeritus of nutritional biochemistry and author of two New York Times best-sellers, "The China Study," and the recently released "Whole," says the healthiest diet excludes animal-based foods including dairy. His research was the basis of the Hollywood 2011 documentary, "Forks over Knives."

Protein, he said, is revered in America without merit. While one's diet should include 5 to 10 percent of daily calories in protein, the average American diet is 17 percent protein.

"Meat is a member of a class of foods that doesn't do much good for anything," he said. "Animal products, if they have any effect at all, tend to be not good. When animal products go up, these diseases go up, and it might not just be because people are consuming more animal food. They also are decreasing plant foods."

Meat, including chicken and fish, contain no antioxidants or complex carbohydrates. Animal protein raises cholesterol while having an effect on insulin or stimulating insulin resistance, he said.

Jeffrey Cohan of Pittsburgh, executive director of Jewish Vegetarians of North America, cites two Old Testament Bible verses -- Genesis 1:29 and Numbers 11:32-34 -- to support a plant-food diet from a religious perspective. He said people who cherish good health should consider grilling veggie burgers, fruits and vegetables on the Fourth of July.

"What the meat industry fears most is delicious plant-based dishes, especially for the Fourth of July," he said.

"Put them on the grill and grill fruit and vegetables on the Fourth," Mr. Cohan said. "These are great alternatives to standard, unhealthy hamburgers and hot dogs that we're accustomed to buying."

David Templeton: or 412-263-1578.


Hot Topic