Peer-to-peer lending sites a growing presence on the Web

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

Anyone who's ever lent a chunk of money to a relative or friend knows it can be a murky proposition fraught with sticky questions and daunting problems.

How much should you lend? Do you charge interest? If so, how much is fair? How long should the borrower get to pay it back? Then there's the unpleasant task of reminding a dawdling dear one that payments are due, not to mention the realization that your "loan" has morphed into a gift.

Enter the so-called peer-to-peer lending business, an emerging arena of financial Web sites that help arrange and manage loans between family members, friends and -- as whacky as it may sound -- total strangers.

The sites all work a little differently, but were founded on a common principle of cutting out the middle man, which helps borrowers get a lower interest rate than they might through traditional sources such as a bank or credit card issuer.

Instead of making money on the interest rate spread, the sites take their cut solely through fees for arranging and servicing the loan.

At, a San Francisco-based site launched in February 2006 by the co-founder and former chief executive officer of online broker E-Loan, Chris Larsen, borrowers post how much money they're seeking (from $1,000 to $25,000) and the top interest rate they are willing to pay. Potential lenders bid to finance an entire loan, or more typically, pieces of loans. The bids with the lowest rates win.

Prosper collects an origination fee from the borrower ranging from 1 percent to 2 percent of the loan and an annual servicing fee from the lender of between 0.5 percent and 1 percent of the outstanding balance.

The company collects and disburses monthly payments on the loans, which are all made for three years.

"Clearly there is a market for this," said Greg McBride, financial analyst with, which tracks consumer finance rates and trends.

Borrowers are turning to the sites as an attractive alternative to high-rate credit card loans, payday loans and other small unsecured loans that many banks won't offer, he said.

Lenders -- basically anyone with a spare $50 -- are attracted by the prospect of earning higher returns than they may get elsewhere, such as in a bank CD.

At Prosper, borrowers go through a credit check and get guidance about what to put in their listing, which must include their credit rating. For example, they may want to note any colleges they attended, which could sway a fellow alumnus to offer a better interest rate.

Lenders and borrowers are given market benchmarks to help them set and choose rates.

People can chose to lend to only the most highly rated borrowers and accept a lower interest rate, or make riskier loans to boost their returns.

There's no limit on the amount someone can lend -- several people have lent more than $1 million, Mr. Larsen said -- but the company recommends people minimize risk by lending in $50 to $100 increments to a diversity of borrowers.

"It's early in the history of Prosper, so defaults are still fairly small, but we would expect them to come up over time," he said.

Investors should expect typical market default rates of around 1/2 percent for borrowers with the best credit ratings up to about 15 percent to 20 percent for those with the poorest scores, he said.

Another peer-to-peer lending site that arranges loans between strangers,, which was launched in Britain in 2005, has said it plans to begin operating in the United States later this year.

Unlike Prosper and Zopa, industry pioneer CircleLending, based in Waltham, Mass., deals strictly with loans between friends and family. There are no limits on the size or term of the loans, which include home mortgages.

The company charges an upfront fee ranging from $99 for an unsecured personal loan to $699 for a mortgage, which includes recording fees with the state. Lenders pay a servicing fee of $9 per payment.

Since its launch in 2001, CircleLending has arranged about $225 million in loans between thousands of people, according to founder and CEO Asheesh Advani, a former development consultant at World Bank in Washington, D.C.

Typical CircleLending customers are looking for money to finance a small business, buy a home or to shore up personal finances, such as consolidating credit card debt or paying for school or medical bills.

Because lenders are restricted to family or friends, their motivation is less about getting a great interest rate and more about "helping and earning a fair return," Mr. Advani said.

Unlike, loans are not spread among multiple lenders counting on monthly payments, so the parties have the flexibility to restructure a loan if the borrower runs into a temporary cash crunch, extending the payback period, for instance, making it more likely the loan is ultimately repaid, Mr. Advani said.

"If you borrow from a bank, [it doesn't] give you any leeway," but just hammers you when payments are late, he said.

For, business has been hampered so far in Pennsylvania by a state statute that sets a maximum interest rate of 6 percent annually on loans of less than $50,000. That makes it hard for Pennsylvania borrowers to attract lenders on the site, Mr. Larsen said.

State and federal laws have carved out exemptions that allow banks and other entities in the state to charge more than 6 percent, but Pennsylvania regulators are still determining whether qualifies.

"We're trying to work with regulators, but it takes time," Mr. Larsen said.

CircleLending said the 6 percent ceiling "has not come up as an issue" because lenders know borrowers and are more interested in helping out than making a hefty return.

The Pennsylvania Department of Banking had little to say about the peer-to-peer lending business, other than the agency has noticed significant growth recently.

Officials are examining whether this new type of lending operation should be required to be licensed in the state, spokeswoman Heather Tyler said last week.

For now, she said, "As always, the banking department urges consumers to use caution and do their homework in selecting a financial service provider."

Mr. McBride of said people considering lending their money through peer-to-peer sites should understand the risks.

The big one of course is defaults.

"It doesn't matter how great the rate is; if someone is not paying you, you aren't making any money," he said.

Prepayments also can erode returns if the investor is unable to quickly re-lend the money at a similar rate.

For borrowers, "Understand that if you default on a loan, they hire a collection agency to track you down and collect the money," Mr. McBride said.

"This is not a free lunch. You have to make your payments, just like you have to make the house and car payments every month."

Patricia Sabatini can be reached at or 412-263-3066.

You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here