Q. Why do so many audio fans seem to prefer a vintage receiver over new receivers with modern technology? Are there actual reasons that older equipment can sound different or better?
I have a Technics SA-600 stereo receiver from the late 1970s. I purchased a new Denon surround sound receiver thinking it would be an improvement, but I didn’t like it! It was just way too complicated to use, and even though the Denon supposedly had more power, music just didn’t sound as enjoyable as with the Technics. I used the same turntable, CD player and speakers for the comparison.
— K.R., South Bend, Ind.
A. When it comes to receivers and amplifiers, older can be better. The amplifier sections in new receivers often don't have the power and electrical current capability of vintage models, especially going from a stereo receiver to a surround sound receiver as you did. The manufacturers saved money by cutting quality in surround receivers’ amplifier sections, then used the savings to add new features such as extra channels for more speakers, Bluetooth, etc.
The power ratings in new gear are often inflated as well. In real-world use, your Technics may actually deliver more power to the speakers, despite the Denon’s higher advertised power rating. In addition, many receivers digitally process everything, including the volume control. Some believe that this digital processing degrades the sound.
There is also the possibility that the Technics’ power is not as “clean” as the Denon and has more distortion, but the mild distortion lends a pleasant quality to the music. That is the reason lots of people prefer tube amplifiers or vintage speakers. Though the old equipment may not reproduce the music as accurately as modern gear, the listener may simply prefer the sound from the vintage equipment.
In general, though, I think if you choose carefully, you can get better sound with modern equipment than with vintage. You just have to be careful about what you buy and how you match components. There is good stuff and bad stuff littering every price point, and one of the goals of this column is to point out the good stuff so readers can get great results no matter their budget.
You can get much more speaker for your dollar than you could years ago. Most modern turntables will sound better, too, but much of that is by virtue of their newness. Old turntables can have worn platter and tonearm bearings, which seriously degrade the sound.
As you discovered, it is in the realm of amplifiers and receivers that quality has taken the biggest hit. For stereo, if your budget is under $500, a vintage amplifier or receiver could very well be the best choice if you have access to a clean example that works perfectly.
The problem for the average consumer is knowing what brands are best and what to look for so you get a reliable unit. The “golden age” for vintage audio was probably the 1980s, and some great, affordable audiophile brands are Adcom, B&K, Harman/Kardon, NAD and Rotel.
Fortunately, some manufacturers have started to fill the void with high-quality receivers and amplifiers that most people can afford. Emotiva is a champion at this. The Emotiva TA-100 stereo tuner/amplifier — same as a receiver — provides high-end sound and 50 strong watts of power for $399.
For surround sound, an Emotiva MC-700 preamp/processor paired with an A500 amplifier for a total of $1,098 — called “separates” rather than a receiver — will outperform most any surround sound receiver and will have flexibility for later upgrading as well. See emotiva.com
Read past columns and product reviews by Don Lindich at www.soundadvicenews.com.