 High-tech
creatures of different shapes, speeds
March 7, 1999
By Michael Newman, Post-Gazette Staff Writer
| |
Chart

High Tech: Gorillas & Gazelles |
For an economist, David Birch knows a lot about animals. In the
menagerie of the business world, unlike that of the natural world, they can be difficult
to recognize.
Birch, the president of Cognetics, a Massachusetts economics-research
firm, coined the term "gazelle" more than a decade ago. It refers to a small,
nimble company that is growing quickly.
There are others in the zoo. A "gorilla," for instance
also called an "elephant" is defined as large and slow-moving, while
"mice" start and stay small. But from an economic perspective, sometimes
gorillas run like gazelles especially in the field of high technology.
Take the example of Warrendale-based Fore Systems, which is probably the
largest local gorilla, with more than 900 of its 1,900 employees based in the region. It
is also hiring at a rate of 20 per month.
"Weve got kind of gazelle legs with a gorilla body,"
spokesman Rich Borden says.
Regions, like companies, can be difficult to categorize. Pittsburgh, for
instance, is just below average as a gorilla; as a gazelle, it is just above average. In
both categories, it ranks in the bottom half when measured against other PG Benchmarks
cities.
According to the WEFA Group, an economic-research consulting firm based
near Philadelphia, in 1997 Pittsburghs "gazelle" score was 101.3, just
above both the national average of 100 and last years score of 99.3. It thus places
12th of the 15 Benchmarks cities, one rung higher than last year.
The WEFA Group defines a gazelle as a region that is adding high-tech
jobs quickly. If high-tech jobs in a given region grow at the same rate as the national
rate, the region scores 100. If jobs grow 25 percent faster than the national rate, the
score is 125; 25 percent slower, the score is 75. The most "gazelle-like" region
of the 15 included in the PG Benchmarks survey was Atlanta, with a rating of 141.12.
And what about the gorilla metaphor? WEFA defines a gorilla as a region
with a high concentration of high-tech jobs. By that it means the percentage of high-tech
jobs in relation to all jobs. If the regional percentage matches that of the national
economy, it is assigned a score of 1.0. If its twice as high as the national
average, its score is 2.0; half of it would result in a score of 0.5.
As a gorilla, Pittsburgh is smaller than average, with a score of 0.87
a decrease of 6 percentage points from last years score of 0.93. It gained
slightly on its Benchmarks cohorts, ranking ninth of the 15 Benchmarks regions compared to
10th last year. The Denver-Boulder-Greeley metropolitan area is the biggest gorilla, with
a score of 1.66.
One of the ways to become a gorilla, clearly, is to first become a
gazelle. But whats necessary to become a gazelle? Besides a couple horns and four
hoofed feet?
Birch has some ideas, but no real answers. Many of the most
entrepreneurial cities in the country, he notes, are in the South and West. Yet it is more
than climate or geography that defines an "entrepreneurial culture."
"The entrepreneurial culture is very important," he says.
"Its the attitude of society toward entrepreneurs which clubs do they
join, which boards do they sit on, which banks lend to them.
"Its the old industrial world vs. the new economy," he
says. "Those cities that reflect that new economy are doing well. Those that
dont, arent."
Fore Systems year-old marketing campaign may thus have some
relevance. Featuring grimy steelworkers in industrial settings, it carries the slogan:
"Were from Pittsburgh. We build networks that last."
The campaign is designed to heighten the high-tech profile of both the
company and the region without ignoring its more low-tech heritage. The impact of
such marketing is difficult to gauge, of course, but Borden says its had one
measurable effect:
Hundreds of former Pittsburghers from around the country have inundated
the company with requests for a poster version of the ad even though they may not
know or view Pittsburgh as a high-tech region.
"They say, I really dont know what you make, but this
strikes a chord with me," Borden says. "They really want that
poster."
|