Reality Check: Nurses group wants to scrub 'Scrubbing In'
November 8, 2013 7:38 PM
James Wolpert performing on "The Voice."
By Maria Sciullo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
That did not take long.
After one airing of MTV's new show "Scrubbing In," the National Association of Clinical Nurse Specialists has called for cancellation of the show.
Sort of "Real World" meets "Grey's Anatomy," the show features a young cast with five Pittsburgh-area nurses from Allegheny General Hospital's ICU. They sign on as travel nurses and soon are off to California, where they meet others in their profession who will work and drink alongside them.
James Wolpert continues to impress on 'The Voice'
Former CMU student James Wolpert performs solo on NBC's "The Voice." (Video courtesy of NBC; 11/9/2013)
At the Television Critics Association summer press tour, cast member Crystal Burrell told the Post-Gazette's Rob Owen that producers promised a "healthy balance of inside and outside of work."
The first episode wasn't even close, with mere glimpses of the nurses at work and more concentration on partying and personal conflicts. It's possible, but unlikely, the focus will turn to nursing in future episodes. But this is MTV, which doesn't have "Buckwild" or "Jersey Shore" anymore, and "Catfish" is casting things in the worst possible light.
The "Scrubbing In" pilot had a scene in which one nurse jumps into a shower to surprise another, and you just know whose idea that was.
Hint: not the nurses'.
Heather Ambrose, Nikki Cirrincione, Michelle Battisti and Chelsey Ferri are the other women with local ties portrayed on the show.
NACNS president Carol Manchester has written to MTV, objecting that "Scrubbing In" shows the nurses "in a disrespectful and unfair light for purely salacious purposes. ... At a time when our nation needs nurses more than ever, this program is denigrating and demeaning the members of what has been shown time and again to be one of the most trusted professions in the United States."
Also on reality TV ...
■ It was a good sign that by the time Thursday's first live results show of NBC's "The Voice" aired, James Wolpert had the best-selling music video among the contestants. Singers' votes can be boosted by iTunes chart standings this season.
The former Carnegie Mellon University art student was "Saved By America" -- isn't that just the best phrase? -- and will compete in the Top 12 next week.
■ What's a wedding without tears of joy?
On the Nov. 1 edition of CBS's "Undercover Boss," a Pittsburgh bridal show was the setting for one of the segments. Paul Quentel, president of Florida-based bridal giant Alfred Angelo, spent time here in July, chatting with brides as he pretended to be a personal trainer competing on a reality show.
Along the way, he met a young aspiring designer, as well as employees who were deaf, financially strapped and a manager who was once homeless. The usual big "Undercover Boss" reveal at the end was particularly satisfying, with tears all around and some nice bonuses.
To report inappropriate comments, abuse and/or repeat offenders, please send an email to
firstname.lastname@example.org and include a link to the article and a copy of the comment. Your report will be reviewed in a timely manner.