Book review

A mighty fortress is our hymn

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

Sure, the ti­tle “28 Hymns to Sing Be­fore You Die” is a gim­mick, but it makes a good point. Tra­di­tion­ally, many Prot­es­tants be­gan sing­ing hymns when they were barely old enough to reach the pew rack, and as any nurs­ing home chap­lain can tell you, of­ten their mem­ory of hymns lives be­yond that of peo­ple or places or even the abil­ity to talk.

Case in point: The Rev. Mor­gan Rob­erts, pas­tor emer­i­tus of Shadyside Pres­by­te­rian Church and co-au­thor of this vol­ume, tells of how his father died while sing­ing “Blessed As­sur­ance.”

Bring­ing per­sonal and other an­ec­dotes to bear, Rev. Rob­erts and co-au­thor the Rev. John Mul­der game­fully con­cede that most pa­rish­io­ners re­mem­ber what they‘‍ve sung rather than the preach­ing they’‍ve sat through. “A verse may finde him, who a ser­mon flies,” the poet George Her­bert con­firmed long ago.

By John M. Mulder, F. Morgan Roberts
Cascade Books ($25)

The au­thors have gath­ered 27 hymns that ap­peared in most ma­jor main­line Prot­es­tant hym­nals from the 19th cen­tury on­ward. (The 28th is “Amaz­ing Grace,” of more re­cent pop­u­lar­ity but a wel­come ex­cep­tion to the cri­te­ria.) The Rev. Mul­der, for­mer pres­i­dent of Lou­is­ville Pres­by­te­rian Theo­log­i­cal Sem­i­nary, writes the backstory to these hymns, fol­lowed by med­i­ta­tions by Rev. Rob­erts.

Their se­lec­tion cri­te­ria limit the hymns to those sung by mostly white wor­shipp­ers in mostly tall-stee­ple churches. Gospel clas­sics of black, white and mixed vin­tage — “His Eye is on the Spar­row,” “Wade in the Water” — didn’‍t cross the cul­tural di­vide from the camp meet­ing to hym­nal un­til more re­cently.

Thus the book omits the clas­sics of Fanny Crosby‘‍s rep­er­toire, in­clud­ing “Blessed As­sur­ance” and “Pass Me Not, Oh Gen­tle Sav­ior” (in ei­ther its tra­di­tional or MC Ham­mer ver­sions). Mod­ern gui­tar-led praise mu­sic — which is all that many church-go­ers to­day have ever sung — is omit­ted.

That said, the book in­cludes many mu­si­cal and po­etic mas­ter­pieces — and cul­tural mile­stones. One can hardly un­der­stand 16th-cen­tury his­tory with­out know­ing that “A Mighty For­tress Is Our God” fired up the Refor­ma­tion troops far more than 95 the­ses that no­body re­mem­bers to­day.

The book tells of in­tensely pain­ful, per­sonal sto­ries be­hind hymns that most of us know in their Sun­day best. The words to the Palm Sun­day an­them “All Glory, Laud and Honor” were com­posed by a cleric in the squa­lor of a me­di­e­val prison, its mu­sic by an ail­ing, im­pov­er­ished min­is­ter cen­tu­ries later.

“Just As I Am,” the an­them of 20th-cen­tury Billy Graham cru­sades, was writ­ten by 19th-cen­tury English­woman Char­lotte El­li­ott in the throes of phys­i­cal pain and de­pres­sion. Her in­sis­tence on an­o­nym­ity was suc­cess­ful enough that a doc­tor once gave her a copy of the hymn to cheer her up.

The late Rev. Fred Rogers, the Pitts­burgh chil­dren’‍s TV pi­o­neer, ap­pears in these pages. Rev. Rob­erts ties “Just As I Am” to Mis­ter Rogers’‍ re­lent­less af­fir­ma­tions, “I like you just the way you are,” and “No one else can fill your sneak­ers!”

And Rev. Rob­erts even in­vokes Mis­ter Rogers in dis­cuss­ing the apoc­a­lyp­tic bat­tles of “A Mighty For­tress,” say­ing he was far from “na­ive about the power of evil“ in chil­dren‘‍s lives but urg­ing all to ”make our neigh­bor­hoods sanc­tu­ar­ies of kind­ness and for­give­ness.”

Peter Smith is the Post-Ga­zette’s re­li­gion re­porter: ps­mith@ post-ga­

Join the conversation:

Commenting policy | How to report abuse
To report inappropriate comments, abuse and/or repeat offenders, please send an email to and include a link to the article and a copy of the comment. Your report will be reviewed in a timely manner. Thank you.
Commenting policy | How to report abuse

Create a free PG account.
Already have an account?

You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here