Joe Nocera / The coach who fought back

Tim Cohane, like so many others, was railroaded by the NCAA

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

In 1966, Beryl Shipley, the basketball coach at the University of Southwestern Louisiana, recruited three African-Americans to play for the Ragin' Cajuns. Although the school, now known as the University of Louisiana at Lafayette, had accepted black students since the mid-1950s, its teams remained segregated -- as did every college athletic team in the state.

Louisiana's Board of Education quickly moved to stop Mr. Shipley. First, it demanded that Mr. Shipley hold practice a week earlier than NCAA rules allowed. Then, according to "Slam Dunked," a book Mr. Shipley wrote with Ron Gomez, the board told the school that athletic scholarships could be granted only to whites. Rather than cut his players loose, Mr. Shipley funded the scholarships with money raised from local boosters.

The Board of Education reacted by informing the NCAA that Mr. Shipley and the university were in violation of NCAA rules.

An organization with a moral compass would have refused to allow itself to be a pawn in a segregationist effort to preserve an all-white team. But the NCAA has never had a moral compass. So instead, it assigned a new hire, Warren Brown, to investigate, and, in 1968, it issued the first in a series of harsh penalties: two years' probation, with no television or postseason appearances during that time. Mr. Shipley left college coaching, in disgust, in 1973. Mr. Brown rose to become the NCAA's enforcement chief.

What brought this long-forgotten story to mind was the sight, last Thursday, of another coach who'd been railroaded unfairly with the willing participation of the NCAA. Tim Cohane, 70, sat in a federal courthouse in Buffalo, while his lawyer, Sean O'Leary, argued that his long-running lawsuits against the NCAA, the Mid-America Conference and SUNY Buffalo, where he was once head basketball coach, deserved to be heard by a jury. Mr. Cohane's essential complaint is that in 1999, a new athletic director, Bob Arkeilpane, ginned up a series of phony NCAA rules violations to force out Mr. Cohane. (As a state employee with a contract, Mr. Cohane was difficult to fire without cause.)

And, once again, the NCAA obliged. Although the primary alleged violation -- watching prospects work out in a gym -- is incredibly insignificant, the NCAA charged Mr. Cohane with unethical conduct and hit him with a dreaded "show cause" order. Any school that wanted to hire him as head coach would have had to explain its decision to the NCAA. Branded with that Scarlet "A," as Mr. O'Leary put it in court, Mr. Cohane's career as a college head coach was over.

In legal terms, the importance of the Cohane case is that, should he win, the NCAA would be labeled a "state actor." It would then have to employ real due process, just like any state agency. It would upend a 25-year-old Supreme Court ruling, in a famous case involving Jerry Tarkanian, the former head coach at the University of Nevada-Las Vegas, that the NCAA was not a state actor. Thus it could treat those under its purview as shabbily as it saw fit -- which it has done ever since.

At the hearing, the NCAA's lawyer argued that the case should be tossed solely because his client was not a state actor. To the NCAA, its despicable role in destroying Mr. Cohane's career is irrelevant.

When it was his turn to speak, Mr. O'Leary, a fiery man who once played for Mr. Cohane, angrily dredged up examples of heinous behavior by the defendants. How, with the seniors' eligibility having expired, thus putting them out of reach of the NCAA, the school threatened to withhold their diplomas if they didn't cooperate with investigators. How several players who had sided with Mr. Cohane were pressured to change their tune. How the Mid-America Conference secretly back-dated a damning report -- a report Mr. Cohane only discovered seven years into the litigation.

How a back channel developed between the conference and the NCAA as they conspired to give Mr. Arkeilpane what he wanted: a report that would doom the coach. (Mr. Arkeilpane, now at the University of Cincinnati, declined comment.) How a Buffalo assistant coach whom Mr. Cohane had decided to fire after he was caught in a hotel room groping two high school girls -- a photo of the incident is part of the evidence -- was the only one of Mr. Cohane's staff to keep his job. The NCAA and SUNY Buffalo gave him a pass because he had aided in the investigation.

I have no insight into whether Mr. Cohane will prevail. During nearly a decade's worth of litigation, the lower courts have generally been hostile to Mr. Cohane, while the court of appeals has sided with him.

What I do know is that Mr. Cohane is the first head coach since Mr. Tarkanian to stand and fight when the NCAA brought dubious charges without any due process. A Cohane victory would help restore some integrity to a process that has been corrupt at least since the days of Beryl Shipley and Southwestern Louisiana.


Joe Nocera is a columnist for The New York Times.


Create a free PG account.
Already have an account?